"Written feedback doesn't make sense": Enhancing assessment feedback using technologies

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference PaperResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Research reveals that effective assessment feedback is clear, specific, and sensitive to the individual. In practice, comments on assessment tasks are commonly provided in a text-based format, which can be perceived by students as ambiguous and impersonal. Digitally recorded comments, in the form of audio, video, or screencast recordings, may present a clearer and more personal alternative to text-based feedback. However, at this stage, research tends to be restrained to the higher education setting. This paper builds upon previous research by examining perceptions of digitally recorded assessment feedback in an Australian Catholic girls’ secondary school. Thirteen teachers from eight broad subject areas (English, Math, Science, IT, Languages, Psychology, Music, and PE/Health) provided recorded comments to students in Years 7-12. To gauge perceptions of the digitally recorded assessment feedback, 262 students completed an anonymous online survey. In support of previous research, the majority of students preferred digitally recorded feedback to text-based feedback, reporting that it was more individualised, detailed, clear, useful, and caring. Several advantages and challenges also emerged from open-ended responses. Further research should aim to examine the relationship between the affordances of the media itself, the instructional content and its structure, and the ecology of the individual classes.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationAARE Conference Proceedings 2016
PublisherAustralian Association for Research in Education
Pages1-11
Number of pages11
Publication statusPublished - 2016
EventInternational Conference of the Australian Association for Research in Education 2016: Transforming Educational Research - Melbourne Cricket Ground Function Centre, Melbourne, Australia
Duration: 27 Nov 20161 Dec 2016

Conference

ConferenceInternational Conference of the Australian Association for Research in Education 2016
Abbreviated titleAARE 2016
CountryAustralia
CityMelbourne
Period27/11/161/12/16

Cite this

Ryan, T. A., Henderson, M., & Phillips, M. D. (2016). "Written feedback doesn't make sense": Enhancing assessment feedback using technologies. In AARE Conference Proceedings 2016 (pp. 1-11). Australian Association for Research in Education.
Ryan, Tracii Ann ; Henderson, Michael ; Phillips, Michael David. / "Written feedback doesn't make sense" : Enhancing assessment feedback using technologies. AARE Conference Proceedings 2016. Australian Association for Research in Education, 2016. pp. 1-11
@inproceedings{227428a5c17c447299e5564bd07e2bc7,
title = "{"}Written feedback doesn't make sense{"}: Enhancing assessment feedback using technologies",
abstract = "Research reveals that effective assessment feedback is clear, specific, and sensitive to the individual. In practice, comments on assessment tasks are commonly provided in a text-based format, which can be perceived by students as ambiguous and impersonal. Digitally recorded comments, in the form of audio, video, or screencast recordings, may present a clearer and more personal alternative to text-based feedback. However, at this stage, research tends to be restrained to the higher education setting. This paper builds upon previous research by examining perceptions of digitally recorded assessment feedback in an Australian Catholic girls’ secondary school. Thirteen teachers from eight broad subject areas (English, Math, Science, IT, Languages, Psychology, Music, and PE/Health) provided recorded comments to students in Years 7-12. To gauge perceptions of the digitally recorded assessment feedback, 262 students completed an anonymous online survey. In support of previous research, the majority of students preferred digitally recorded feedback to text-based feedback, reporting that it was more individualised, detailed, clear, useful, and caring. Several advantages and challenges also emerged from open-ended responses. Further research should aim to examine the relationship between the affordances of the media itself, the instructional content and its structure, and the ecology of the individual classes.",
author = "Ryan, {Tracii Ann} and Michael Henderson and Phillips, {Michael David}",
year = "2016",
language = "English",
pages = "1--11",
booktitle = "AARE Conference Proceedings 2016",
publisher = "Australian Association for Research in Education",
address = "Australia",

}

Ryan, TA, Henderson, M & Phillips, MD 2016, "Written feedback doesn't make sense": Enhancing assessment feedback using technologies. in AARE Conference Proceedings 2016. Australian Association for Research in Education, pp. 1-11, International Conference of the Australian Association for Research in Education 2016, Melbourne, Australia, 27/11/16.

"Written feedback doesn't make sense" : Enhancing assessment feedback using technologies. / Ryan, Tracii Ann; Henderson, Michael; Phillips, Michael David.

AARE Conference Proceedings 2016. Australian Association for Research in Education, 2016. p. 1-11.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference PaperResearchpeer-review

TY - GEN

T1 - "Written feedback doesn't make sense"

T2 - Enhancing assessment feedback using technologies

AU - Ryan, Tracii Ann

AU - Henderson, Michael

AU - Phillips, Michael David

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - Research reveals that effective assessment feedback is clear, specific, and sensitive to the individual. In practice, comments on assessment tasks are commonly provided in a text-based format, which can be perceived by students as ambiguous and impersonal. Digitally recorded comments, in the form of audio, video, or screencast recordings, may present a clearer and more personal alternative to text-based feedback. However, at this stage, research tends to be restrained to the higher education setting. This paper builds upon previous research by examining perceptions of digitally recorded assessment feedback in an Australian Catholic girls’ secondary school. Thirteen teachers from eight broad subject areas (English, Math, Science, IT, Languages, Psychology, Music, and PE/Health) provided recorded comments to students in Years 7-12. To gauge perceptions of the digitally recorded assessment feedback, 262 students completed an anonymous online survey. In support of previous research, the majority of students preferred digitally recorded feedback to text-based feedback, reporting that it was more individualised, detailed, clear, useful, and caring. Several advantages and challenges also emerged from open-ended responses. Further research should aim to examine the relationship between the affordances of the media itself, the instructional content and its structure, and the ecology of the individual classes.

AB - Research reveals that effective assessment feedback is clear, specific, and sensitive to the individual. In practice, comments on assessment tasks are commonly provided in a text-based format, which can be perceived by students as ambiguous and impersonal. Digitally recorded comments, in the form of audio, video, or screencast recordings, may present a clearer and more personal alternative to text-based feedback. However, at this stage, research tends to be restrained to the higher education setting. This paper builds upon previous research by examining perceptions of digitally recorded assessment feedback in an Australian Catholic girls’ secondary school. Thirteen teachers from eight broad subject areas (English, Math, Science, IT, Languages, Psychology, Music, and PE/Health) provided recorded comments to students in Years 7-12. To gauge perceptions of the digitally recorded assessment feedback, 262 students completed an anonymous online survey. In support of previous research, the majority of students preferred digitally recorded feedback to text-based feedback, reporting that it was more individualised, detailed, clear, useful, and caring. Several advantages and challenges also emerged from open-ended responses. Further research should aim to examine the relationship between the affordances of the media itself, the instructional content and its structure, and the ecology of the individual classes.

M3 - Conference Paper

SP - 1

EP - 11

BT - AARE Conference Proceedings 2016

PB - Australian Association for Research in Education

ER -

Ryan TA, Henderson M, Phillips MD. "Written feedback doesn't make sense": Enhancing assessment feedback using technologies. In AARE Conference Proceedings 2016. Australian Association for Research in Education. 2016. p. 1-11