Understanding the civic impact of journalism:

A realistic evaluation perspective

Margaret Simons, Rodney Tiffen, Doug Hendrie, Andrea Carson, Helen Sullivan, Denis Muller, Brian McNair

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

The importance of journalism to civil society is constantly proclaimed, but empirical evidence on journalism's impact, and how this operates, is surprisingly thin. Indeed, there is confusion even about what is meant by the term “impact”. Meanwhile, the issue of the role of journalism is becoming increasingly urgent as a consequence of the rapid changes engulfing the news media, brought about by technological change and the flow-on effect to the traditional advertising-supported business model. Assessing the impact of journalism has recently been the topic of debate among practitioners and scholars particularly in the United States, where philanthropists have responded to the perceived crisis in investigative journalism by funding not-for-profit newsrooms, with resulting new pressures being placed on journalists and editors to quantify their impact on society. These recent attempts have so far failed to achieve clarity or a satisfactory conclusion, which is not surprising given the complex web of causation within which journalism operates. In this paper, the authors propose a stratified definition of journalistic impact and function. They propose a methodology for studying impact drawing on realistic evaluation—a theory-based approach developed primarily to assess large social programmes occurring in open systems. The authors argue this could allow a conceptual and methodological advance on the question of media impacts, leading to research capable of usefully informing responses at a time of worrying change.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1400-1414
Number of pages15
JournalJournalism Studies
Volume18
Issue number11
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2017
Externally publishedYes

Keywords

  • journalism
  • journalism impact
  • media
  • media effects

Cite this

Simons, M., Tiffen, R., Hendrie, D., Carson, A., Sullivan, H., Muller, D., & McNair, B. (2017). Understanding the civic impact of journalism: A realistic evaluation perspective. Journalism Studies, 18(11), 1400-1414. https://doi.org/10.1080/1461670X.2015.1129284
Simons, Margaret ; Tiffen, Rodney ; Hendrie, Doug ; Carson, Andrea ; Sullivan, Helen ; Muller, Denis ; McNair, Brian. / Understanding the civic impact of journalism: A realistic evaluation perspective. In: Journalism Studies. 2017 ; Vol. 18, No. 11. pp. 1400-1414.
@article{17163d8577c0417786e2ce39e52a6f3d,
title = "Understanding the civic impact of journalism:: A realistic evaluation perspective",
abstract = "The importance of journalism to civil society is constantly proclaimed, but empirical evidence on journalism's impact, and how this operates, is surprisingly thin. Indeed, there is confusion even about what is meant by the term “impact”. Meanwhile, the issue of the role of journalism is becoming increasingly urgent as a consequence of the rapid changes engulfing the news media, brought about by technological change and the flow-on effect to the traditional advertising-supported business model. Assessing the impact of journalism has recently been the topic of debate among practitioners and scholars particularly in the United States, where philanthropists have responded to the perceived crisis in investigative journalism by funding not-for-profit newsrooms, with resulting new pressures being placed on journalists and editors to quantify their impact on society. These recent attempts have so far failed to achieve clarity or a satisfactory conclusion, which is not surprising given the complex web of causation within which journalism operates. In this paper, the authors propose a stratified definition of journalistic impact and function. They propose a methodology for studying impact drawing on realistic evaluation—a theory-based approach developed primarily to assess large social programmes occurring in open systems. The authors argue this could allow a conceptual and methodological advance on the question of media impacts, leading to research capable of usefully informing responses at a time of worrying change.",
keywords = "journalism, journalism impact, media, media effects",
author = "Margaret Simons and Rodney Tiffen and Doug Hendrie and Andrea Carson and Helen Sullivan and Denis Muller and Brian McNair",
year = "2017",
doi = "10.1080/1461670X.2015.1129284",
language = "English",
volume = "18",
pages = "1400--1414",
journal = "Journalism Studies",
issn = "1461-670X",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",
number = "11",

}

Simons, M, Tiffen, R, Hendrie, D, Carson, A, Sullivan, H, Muller, D & McNair, B 2017, 'Understanding the civic impact of journalism: A realistic evaluation perspective', Journalism Studies, vol. 18, no. 11, pp. 1400-1414. https://doi.org/10.1080/1461670X.2015.1129284

Understanding the civic impact of journalism: A realistic evaluation perspective. / Simons, Margaret; Tiffen, Rodney; Hendrie, Doug; Carson, Andrea; Sullivan, Helen; Muller, Denis; McNair, Brian.

In: Journalism Studies, Vol. 18, No. 11, 2017, p. 1400-1414.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Understanding the civic impact of journalism:

T2 - A realistic evaluation perspective

AU - Simons, Margaret

AU - Tiffen, Rodney

AU - Hendrie, Doug

AU - Carson, Andrea

AU - Sullivan, Helen

AU - Muller, Denis

AU - McNair, Brian

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - The importance of journalism to civil society is constantly proclaimed, but empirical evidence on journalism's impact, and how this operates, is surprisingly thin. Indeed, there is confusion even about what is meant by the term “impact”. Meanwhile, the issue of the role of journalism is becoming increasingly urgent as a consequence of the rapid changes engulfing the news media, brought about by technological change and the flow-on effect to the traditional advertising-supported business model. Assessing the impact of journalism has recently been the topic of debate among practitioners and scholars particularly in the United States, where philanthropists have responded to the perceived crisis in investigative journalism by funding not-for-profit newsrooms, with resulting new pressures being placed on journalists and editors to quantify their impact on society. These recent attempts have so far failed to achieve clarity or a satisfactory conclusion, which is not surprising given the complex web of causation within which journalism operates. In this paper, the authors propose a stratified definition of journalistic impact and function. They propose a methodology for studying impact drawing on realistic evaluation—a theory-based approach developed primarily to assess large social programmes occurring in open systems. The authors argue this could allow a conceptual and methodological advance on the question of media impacts, leading to research capable of usefully informing responses at a time of worrying change.

AB - The importance of journalism to civil society is constantly proclaimed, but empirical evidence on journalism's impact, and how this operates, is surprisingly thin. Indeed, there is confusion even about what is meant by the term “impact”. Meanwhile, the issue of the role of journalism is becoming increasingly urgent as a consequence of the rapid changes engulfing the news media, brought about by technological change and the flow-on effect to the traditional advertising-supported business model. Assessing the impact of journalism has recently been the topic of debate among practitioners and scholars particularly in the United States, where philanthropists have responded to the perceived crisis in investigative journalism by funding not-for-profit newsrooms, with resulting new pressures being placed on journalists and editors to quantify their impact on society. These recent attempts have so far failed to achieve clarity or a satisfactory conclusion, which is not surprising given the complex web of causation within which journalism operates. In this paper, the authors propose a stratified definition of journalistic impact and function. They propose a methodology for studying impact drawing on realistic evaluation—a theory-based approach developed primarily to assess large social programmes occurring in open systems. The authors argue this could allow a conceptual and methodological advance on the question of media impacts, leading to research capable of usefully informing responses at a time of worrying change.

KW - journalism

KW - journalism impact

KW - media

KW - media effects

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84958534373&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/1461670X.2015.1129284

DO - 10.1080/1461670X.2015.1129284

M3 - Article

VL - 18

SP - 1400

EP - 1414

JO - Journalism Studies

JF - Journalism Studies

SN - 1461-670X

IS - 11

ER -