Towards Grasping the Unknowable: Networked Hierarchies of Analogies

Andrys Onsman, David Paganin

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference PaperResearchpeer-review

    Abstract

    This paper investigates the purposeful use of analogy in teaching and learning rather than how analogy works as a neuro-cognitive activity. Nonetheless, we shall make some reference to mental processing in order to support our proposals. The use of the word purposeful in this context is taken to mean that analogies are educationally most fruitful in specific contexts. Further, it assumes that an analogy has an optimal potency, which diminishes or increases in relation to complexity and relevance. In turn, this suggests that anologies have inherent disposability, or rather, we suggest, a range of references or applicability. We discuss the notion of a hierarchy of disparate analogies to describe a single instance or event and conclude that because of the capacity to move non-linearly amongst analogies, it is more profitable to refer to a network of analogies that allow specifically purposeful understandings of a fundamentally unknowable concept. In conclusion we suggest that the cognitive strategy that drives the movement within the network is contextually-bound functionalism.
    Original languageEnglish
    Title of host publicationONS091375
    Place of PublicationOn Line
    PublisherAustralian Association for Research in Education
    Pages1 - 14
    Number of pages14
    Publication statusPublished - 2009
    EventInternational Conference of the Australian Association for Research in Education 2009 - Canberra, Australia
    Duration: 29 Nov 20093 Dec 2009

    Conference

    ConferenceInternational Conference of the Australian Association for Research in Education 2009
    Abbreviated titleAARE 2009
    CountryAustralia
    CityCanberra
    Period29/11/093/12/09

    Cite this

    Onsman, A., & Paganin, D. (2009). Towards Grasping the Unknowable: Networked Hierarchies of Analogies. In ONS091375 (pp. 1 - 14). On Line: Australian Association for Research in Education.
    Onsman, Andrys ; Paganin, David. / Towards Grasping the Unknowable: Networked Hierarchies of Analogies. ONS091375. On Line : Australian Association for Research in Education, 2009. pp. 1 - 14
    @inproceedings{05ae50c5d0c5460e9d7ee20b5fa7a44b,
    title = "Towards Grasping the Unknowable: Networked Hierarchies of Analogies",
    abstract = "This paper investigates the purposeful use of analogy in teaching and learning rather than how analogy works as a neuro-cognitive activity. Nonetheless, we shall make some reference to mental processing in order to support our proposals. The use of the word purposeful in this context is taken to mean that analogies are educationally most fruitful in specific contexts. Further, it assumes that an analogy has an optimal potency, which diminishes or increases in relation to complexity and relevance. In turn, this suggests that anologies have inherent disposability, or rather, we suggest, a range of references or applicability. We discuss the notion of a hierarchy of disparate analogies to describe a single instance or event and conclude that because of the capacity to move non-linearly amongst analogies, it is more profitable to refer to a network of analogies that allow specifically purposeful understandings of a fundamentally unknowable concept. In conclusion we suggest that the cognitive strategy that drives the movement within the network is contextually-bound functionalism.",
    author = "Andrys Onsman and David Paganin",
    year = "2009",
    language = "English",
    pages = "1 -- 14",
    booktitle = "ONS091375",
    publisher = "Australian Association for Research in Education",
    address = "Australia",

    }

    Onsman, A & Paganin, D 2009, Towards Grasping the Unknowable: Networked Hierarchies of Analogies. in ONS091375. Australian Association for Research in Education, On Line, pp. 1 - 14, International Conference of the Australian Association for Research in Education 2009, Canberra, Australia, 29/11/09.

    Towards Grasping the Unknowable: Networked Hierarchies of Analogies. / Onsman, Andrys; Paganin, David.

    ONS091375. On Line : Australian Association for Research in Education, 2009. p. 1 - 14.

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference PaperResearchpeer-review

    TY - GEN

    T1 - Towards Grasping the Unknowable: Networked Hierarchies of Analogies

    AU - Onsman, Andrys

    AU - Paganin, David

    PY - 2009

    Y1 - 2009

    N2 - This paper investigates the purposeful use of analogy in teaching and learning rather than how analogy works as a neuro-cognitive activity. Nonetheless, we shall make some reference to mental processing in order to support our proposals. The use of the word purposeful in this context is taken to mean that analogies are educationally most fruitful in specific contexts. Further, it assumes that an analogy has an optimal potency, which diminishes or increases in relation to complexity and relevance. In turn, this suggests that anologies have inherent disposability, or rather, we suggest, a range of references or applicability. We discuss the notion of a hierarchy of disparate analogies to describe a single instance or event and conclude that because of the capacity to move non-linearly amongst analogies, it is more profitable to refer to a network of analogies that allow specifically purposeful understandings of a fundamentally unknowable concept. In conclusion we suggest that the cognitive strategy that drives the movement within the network is contextually-bound functionalism.

    AB - This paper investigates the purposeful use of analogy in teaching and learning rather than how analogy works as a neuro-cognitive activity. Nonetheless, we shall make some reference to mental processing in order to support our proposals. The use of the word purposeful in this context is taken to mean that analogies are educationally most fruitful in specific contexts. Further, it assumes that an analogy has an optimal potency, which diminishes or increases in relation to complexity and relevance. In turn, this suggests that anologies have inherent disposability, or rather, we suggest, a range of references or applicability. We discuss the notion of a hierarchy of disparate analogies to describe a single instance or event and conclude that because of the capacity to move non-linearly amongst analogies, it is more profitable to refer to a network of analogies that allow specifically purposeful understandings of a fundamentally unknowable concept. In conclusion we suggest that the cognitive strategy that drives the movement within the network is contextually-bound functionalism.

    UR - http://ocs.sfu.ca/aare/index.php/AARE_2009/paper/view/1375

    M3 - Conference Paper

    SP - 1

    EP - 14

    BT - ONS091375

    PB - Australian Association for Research in Education

    CY - On Line

    ER -

    Onsman A, Paganin D. Towards Grasping the Unknowable: Networked Hierarchies of Analogies. In ONS091375. On Line: Australian Association for Research in Education. 2009. p. 1 - 14