The portrayal of counselling on television and YouTube: Implications for professional counsellors

Brett Edward Furlonger, Alexandra Papadopoulos, Andrea Ping Chow, Yusi Zhu

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Western visual entertainment media s preference for entertainment over accuracy has produced distorted portrayals of counselling and counsellors. Therefore, the main objective of the present study was to identify whether it was possible for portrayals of counselling in the entertainment media to be realistic while also being entertaining; entertainment being imperative to the entertainment industry. It was hypothesized that if television series were realistic then the counsellor would be shown as using a positive, ethical contemporary counselling approach to dealing with typical client problems. It was also hypothesized that YouTube videos would be more closely representative of actual counselling than television. Two visual entertainment forms were sampled for analyses, a 43 episode television series focussed on a counsellor and 80 counselling videos from YouTube. The study utilised a quantitative exploratory archival survey design that analysed and categorised existing data. Based on set evaluation criteria, analysis indicated that the tendency for television producers to lapse into inaccuracies for dramatic effect appeared irresistible. In contrast, YouTube allowed counsellors to post an unlimited number of accurate representations of counselling videos online, although the entertainment value and popularity was more difficult to assess.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1 - 24
Number of pages24
JournalJournal of Behavioural Sciences
Volume25
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 2015

Cite this

Furlonger, Brett Edward ; Papadopoulos, Alexandra ; Chow, Andrea Ping ; Zhu, Yusi. / The portrayal of counselling on television and YouTube: Implications for professional counsellors. In: Journal of Behavioural Sciences. 2015 ; Vol. 25, No. 2. pp. 1 - 24.
@article{3093ebee58de49f7a3213f959ae1dabe,
title = "The portrayal of counselling on television and YouTube: Implications for professional counsellors",
abstract = "Western visual entertainment media s preference for entertainment over accuracy has produced distorted portrayals of counselling and counsellors. Therefore, the main objective of the present study was to identify whether it was possible for portrayals of counselling in the entertainment media to be realistic while also being entertaining; entertainment being imperative to the entertainment industry. It was hypothesized that if television series were realistic then the counsellor would be shown as using a positive, ethical contemporary counselling approach to dealing with typical client problems. It was also hypothesized that YouTube videos would be more closely representative of actual counselling than television. Two visual entertainment forms were sampled for analyses, a 43 episode television series focussed on a counsellor and 80 counselling videos from YouTube. The study utilised a quantitative exploratory archival survey design that analysed and categorised existing data. Based on set evaluation criteria, analysis indicated that the tendency for television producers to lapse into inaccuracies for dramatic effect appeared irresistible. In contrast, YouTube allowed counsellors to post an unlimited number of accurate representations of counselling videos online, although the entertainment value and popularity was more difficult to assess.",
author = "Furlonger, {Brett Edward} and Alexandra Papadopoulos and Chow, {Andrea Ping} and Yusi Zhu",
year = "2015",
language = "English",
volume = "25",
pages = "1 -- 24",
journal = "Journal of Behavioural Sciences",
issn = "1028-9097",
number = "2",

}

The portrayal of counselling on television and YouTube: Implications for professional counsellors. / Furlonger, Brett Edward; Papadopoulos, Alexandra; Chow, Andrea Ping; Zhu, Yusi.

In: Journal of Behavioural Sciences, Vol. 25, No. 2, 2015, p. 1 - 24.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - The portrayal of counselling on television and YouTube: Implications for professional counsellors

AU - Furlonger, Brett Edward

AU - Papadopoulos, Alexandra

AU - Chow, Andrea Ping

AU - Zhu, Yusi

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - Western visual entertainment media s preference for entertainment over accuracy has produced distorted portrayals of counselling and counsellors. Therefore, the main objective of the present study was to identify whether it was possible for portrayals of counselling in the entertainment media to be realistic while also being entertaining; entertainment being imperative to the entertainment industry. It was hypothesized that if television series were realistic then the counsellor would be shown as using a positive, ethical contemporary counselling approach to dealing with typical client problems. It was also hypothesized that YouTube videos would be more closely representative of actual counselling than television. Two visual entertainment forms were sampled for analyses, a 43 episode television series focussed on a counsellor and 80 counselling videos from YouTube. The study utilised a quantitative exploratory archival survey design that analysed and categorised existing data. Based on set evaluation criteria, analysis indicated that the tendency for television producers to lapse into inaccuracies for dramatic effect appeared irresistible. In contrast, YouTube allowed counsellors to post an unlimited number of accurate representations of counselling videos online, although the entertainment value and popularity was more difficult to assess.

AB - Western visual entertainment media s preference for entertainment over accuracy has produced distorted portrayals of counselling and counsellors. Therefore, the main objective of the present study was to identify whether it was possible for portrayals of counselling in the entertainment media to be realistic while also being entertaining; entertainment being imperative to the entertainment industry. It was hypothesized that if television series were realistic then the counsellor would be shown as using a positive, ethical contemporary counselling approach to dealing with typical client problems. It was also hypothesized that YouTube videos would be more closely representative of actual counselling than television. Two visual entertainment forms were sampled for analyses, a 43 episode television series focussed on a counsellor and 80 counselling videos from YouTube. The study utilised a quantitative exploratory archival survey design that analysed and categorised existing data. Based on set evaluation criteria, analysis indicated that the tendency for television producers to lapse into inaccuracies for dramatic effect appeared irresistible. In contrast, YouTube allowed counsellors to post an unlimited number of accurate representations of counselling videos online, although the entertainment value and popularity was more difficult to assess.

UR - http://goo.gl/MnRqFT

M3 - Article

VL - 25

SP - 1

EP - 24

JO - Journal of Behavioural Sciences

JF - Journal of Behavioural Sciences

SN - 1028-9097

IS - 2

ER -