The impact of recent changes to the respiratory scoring rules in pediatrics

In 2007 the American Academy of Sleep Medicine (AASM) published polysomnography (PSG) scoring guidelines, which were updated in 2012. A key change in terms of scoring respiratory events in children was the threshold for reduction in airflow (50 vs 30 ) for the definition of hypopnea. This study aimed to determine the impact of different scoring rules on the assessment of severity of obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) in children. METHODS: Forty-two children (mean age 4.3 y, 16 F) underwent PSG. An obstructive apnea-hypopnea index (OAHI) was determined using three scoring rules: (1) ATS 1996 rules with minor modifications (modified ATS 1996); (2) AASM 2007 rules (AASM 2007); and (3) AASM 2007 rules with respiratory event related arousals included in the OAHI (AASM+RERA). RESULTS: The AASM 2007 OAHI (median 0.4 events/h, range 0, 14) was lower than the modified ATS 1996 OAHI (median 0.8 range 0, 26.1, p <0.001), underestimating severity of disease in 24 of cases. The AASM+RERA OAHI (median 0.8, range 0, 19.1) was also lower than the modified ATS 1996 OAHI (p = 0.02), but the difference was not clinically significant except at very high OAHIs. CONCLUSION: The AASM 2007 rules lead to a lower OAHI and lesser OSA severity when compared to the previous standard. Inclusion of RERAs in the AASM 2007 OAHI leads to a comparable OAHI to the previous rules. Given that morbidity has been demonstrated even in mild OSA, these results support the inclusion of events with a reduction in airflow of less than 50 as included in the updated AASM rules in 2012.