The factors that influence junior doctors’ capacity to recognise, respond and manage patient deterioration in an acute ward setting: An integrative review

Adele Callaghan, Leigh Kinsman, Simon Cooper, Natalie Radomski

Research output: Contribution to journalReview ArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Objectives Junior doctors are frequently the first doctor to be called by a nurse to review patients whose clinical status has declined in hospital wards, yet little is known about how well prepared they are to deal with this situation. This paper aims to identify the factors that influence junior doctors’ early recognition and management of patient deterioration in an acute ward settings. Method Integrative review methodology was used to allow for the inclusion of broad research designs, summarising current knowledge from existing research and identify gaps in the literature. Quantitative, qualitative and mixed method studies were included. An electronic database search including PubMed, Medline and Scopus was performed. Research articles, exploring junior doctors’ skills specific to critically ill, or deteriorating patients, technical and non-technical skills and failure to rescue were included. Findings Thirty-three articles were included, of which eighteen were quantitative, six qualitative and nine mixed methods The majority of the studies, eighteen out of thirty-three, were from the United Kingdom. The evidence showed that the capacity for junior doctors to effectively deal with patient deterioration was influenced by: educational models that incorporated non-technical skills; the integration of high quality clinical simulation into education; and the level and type of supervision in the clinical environment. Conclusion The factors that influence junior doctors’ capacity to recognise, respond and manage patient deterioration in an acute ward settings are complex. This review indicates that there is substantial room for improvement in junior doctors’ capacity to deal with patient deterioration. Evidence suggests preparation of junior doctors in the recognition and management of the deteriorating patient is influenced by effective simulation education and clinical experiential exposure over time. More accessible supervision for junior doctors in acute wards is recommended to avert error and delays in the appropriate escalation of care in the deteriorating patient.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)197-209
Number of pages13
JournalAustralian Critical Care
Volume30
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jul 2017

Keywords

  • Clinical deterioration
  • Escalation of care
  • Failure to rescue
  • Integrative review
  • Junior doctor
  • Patient deterioration
  • Technical and non-technical skills

Cite this

@article{343ebcd03289468d90a722731cce4720,
title = "The factors that influence junior doctors’ capacity to recognise, respond and manage patient deterioration in an acute ward setting: An integrative review",
abstract = "Objectives Junior doctors are frequently the first doctor to be called by a nurse to review patients whose clinical status has declined in hospital wards, yet little is known about how well prepared they are to deal with this situation. This paper aims to identify the factors that influence junior doctors’ early recognition and management of patient deterioration in an acute ward settings. Method Integrative review methodology was used to allow for the inclusion of broad research designs, summarising current knowledge from existing research and identify gaps in the literature. Quantitative, qualitative and mixed method studies were included. An electronic database search including PubMed, Medline and Scopus was performed. Research articles, exploring junior doctors’ skills specific to critically ill, or deteriorating patients, technical and non-technical skills and failure to rescue were included. Findings Thirty-three articles were included, of which eighteen were quantitative, six qualitative and nine mixed methods The majority of the studies, eighteen out of thirty-three, were from the United Kingdom. The evidence showed that the capacity for junior doctors to effectively deal with patient deterioration was influenced by: educational models that incorporated non-technical skills; the integration of high quality clinical simulation into education; and the level and type of supervision in the clinical environment. Conclusion The factors that influence junior doctors’ capacity to recognise, respond and manage patient deterioration in an acute ward settings are complex. This review indicates that there is substantial room for improvement in junior doctors’ capacity to deal with patient deterioration. Evidence suggests preparation of junior doctors in the recognition and management of the deteriorating patient is influenced by effective simulation education and clinical experiential exposure over time. More accessible supervision for junior doctors in acute wards is recommended to avert error and delays in the appropriate escalation of care in the deteriorating patient.",
keywords = "Clinical deterioration, Escalation of care, Failure to rescue, Integrative review, Junior doctor, Patient deterioration, Technical and non-technical skills",
author = "Adele Callaghan and Leigh Kinsman and Simon Cooper and Natalie Radomski",
year = "2017",
month = "7",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.aucc.2016.09.004",
language = "English",
volume = "30",
pages = "197--209",
journal = "Australian critical care : official journal of the Confederation of Australian Critical Care Nurses",
issn = "1036-7314",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "4",

}

The factors that influence junior doctors’ capacity to recognise, respond and manage patient deterioration in an acute ward setting : An integrative review. / Callaghan, Adele; Kinsman, Leigh; Cooper, Simon; Radomski, Natalie.

In: Australian Critical Care, Vol. 30, No. 4, 01.07.2017, p. 197-209.

Research output: Contribution to journalReview ArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - The factors that influence junior doctors’ capacity to recognise, respond and manage patient deterioration in an acute ward setting

T2 - An integrative review

AU - Callaghan, Adele

AU - Kinsman, Leigh

AU - Cooper, Simon

AU - Radomski, Natalie

PY - 2017/7/1

Y1 - 2017/7/1

N2 - Objectives Junior doctors are frequently the first doctor to be called by a nurse to review patients whose clinical status has declined in hospital wards, yet little is known about how well prepared they are to deal with this situation. This paper aims to identify the factors that influence junior doctors’ early recognition and management of patient deterioration in an acute ward settings. Method Integrative review methodology was used to allow for the inclusion of broad research designs, summarising current knowledge from existing research and identify gaps in the literature. Quantitative, qualitative and mixed method studies were included. An electronic database search including PubMed, Medline and Scopus was performed. Research articles, exploring junior doctors’ skills specific to critically ill, or deteriorating patients, technical and non-technical skills and failure to rescue were included. Findings Thirty-three articles were included, of which eighteen were quantitative, six qualitative and nine mixed methods The majority of the studies, eighteen out of thirty-three, were from the United Kingdom. The evidence showed that the capacity for junior doctors to effectively deal with patient deterioration was influenced by: educational models that incorporated non-technical skills; the integration of high quality clinical simulation into education; and the level and type of supervision in the clinical environment. Conclusion The factors that influence junior doctors’ capacity to recognise, respond and manage patient deterioration in an acute ward settings are complex. This review indicates that there is substantial room for improvement in junior doctors’ capacity to deal with patient deterioration. Evidence suggests preparation of junior doctors in the recognition and management of the deteriorating patient is influenced by effective simulation education and clinical experiential exposure over time. More accessible supervision for junior doctors in acute wards is recommended to avert error and delays in the appropriate escalation of care in the deteriorating patient.

AB - Objectives Junior doctors are frequently the first doctor to be called by a nurse to review patients whose clinical status has declined in hospital wards, yet little is known about how well prepared they are to deal with this situation. This paper aims to identify the factors that influence junior doctors’ early recognition and management of patient deterioration in an acute ward settings. Method Integrative review methodology was used to allow for the inclusion of broad research designs, summarising current knowledge from existing research and identify gaps in the literature. Quantitative, qualitative and mixed method studies were included. An electronic database search including PubMed, Medline and Scopus was performed. Research articles, exploring junior doctors’ skills specific to critically ill, or deteriorating patients, technical and non-technical skills and failure to rescue were included. Findings Thirty-three articles were included, of which eighteen were quantitative, six qualitative and nine mixed methods The majority of the studies, eighteen out of thirty-three, were from the United Kingdom. The evidence showed that the capacity for junior doctors to effectively deal with patient deterioration was influenced by: educational models that incorporated non-technical skills; the integration of high quality clinical simulation into education; and the level and type of supervision in the clinical environment. Conclusion The factors that influence junior doctors’ capacity to recognise, respond and manage patient deterioration in an acute ward settings are complex. This review indicates that there is substantial room for improvement in junior doctors’ capacity to deal with patient deterioration. Evidence suggests preparation of junior doctors in the recognition and management of the deteriorating patient is influenced by effective simulation education and clinical experiential exposure over time. More accessible supervision for junior doctors in acute wards is recommended to avert error and delays in the appropriate escalation of care in the deteriorating patient.

KW - Clinical deterioration

KW - Escalation of care

KW - Failure to rescue

KW - Integrative review

KW - Junior doctor

KW - Patient deterioration

KW - Technical and non-technical skills

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84992391794&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.aucc.2016.09.004

DO - 10.1016/j.aucc.2016.09.004

M3 - Review Article

VL - 30

SP - 197

EP - 209

JO - Australian critical care : official journal of the Confederation of Australian Critical Care Nurses

JF - Australian critical care : official journal of the Confederation of Australian Critical Care Nurses

SN - 1036-7314

IS - 4

ER -