The effect of ‘smart’ financial incentives on driving behaviour of novice drivers

Duncan Mortimer, Jasper S Wijnands, Anthony Harris, Alan Tapp, Mark Stevenson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Recent studies have demonstrated that financial incentives can improve driving behaviour but high-value incentives are unlikely to be cost-effective and attempts to amplify the impact of low-value incentives have so far proven disappointing. The present study provides experimental evidence to inform the design of ‘smart’ and potentially more cost-effective incentives for safe driving in novice drivers. Study participants (n = 78) were randomised to one of four financial incentives: high-value penalty; low-value penalty; high-value reward; low-value reward; allowing us to compare high-value versus low-value incentives, penalties versus rewards, and to test specific hypotheses regarding motivational crowding out and gain/loss asymmetry. Results suggest that (i) penalties may be more effective than rewards of equal value, (ii) even low-value incentives can deliver net reductions in risky driving behaviours and, (iii) increasing the dollar-value of incentives may not increase their effectiveness. These design principles are currently being used to optimise the design of financial incentives embedded within PAYD insurance, with their impact on the driving behaviour of novice drivers to be evaluated in on-road trials.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)68-79
Number of pages12
JournalAccident Analysis and Prevention
Volume119
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Oct 2018

Keywords

  • Behavioural economics
  • Driving behaviour
  • Financial incentives
  • Road safety

Cite this

@article{5f6646814ce4444ab81d1e397f5e19a2,
title = "The effect of ‘smart’ financial incentives on driving behaviour of novice drivers",
abstract = "Recent studies have demonstrated that financial incentives can improve driving behaviour but high-value incentives are unlikely to be cost-effective and attempts to amplify the impact of low-value incentives have so far proven disappointing. The present study provides experimental evidence to inform the design of ‘smart’ and potentially more cost-effective incentives for safe driving in novice drivers. Study participants (n = 78) were randomised to one of four financial incentives: high-value penalty; low-value penalty; high-value reward; low-value reward; allowing us to compare high-value versus low-value incentives, penalties versus rewards, and to test specific hypotheses regarding motivational crowding out and gain/loss asymmetry. Results suggest that (i) penalties may be more effective than rewards of equal value, (ii) even low-value incentives can deliver net reductions in risky driving behaviours and, (iii) increasing the dollar-value of incentives may not increase their effectiveness. These design principles are currently being used to optimise the design of financial incentives embedded within PAYD insurance, with their impact on the driving behaviour of novice drivers to be evaluated in on-road trials.",
keywords = "Behavioural economics, Driving behaviour, Financial incentives, Road safety",
author = "Duncan Mortimer and Wijnands, {Jasper S} and Anthony Harris and Alan Tapp and Mark Stevenson",
year = "2018",
month = "10",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.aap.2018.06.014",
language = "English",
volume = "119",
pages = "68--79",
journal = "Accident Analysis and Prevention",
issn = "0001-4575",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

The effect of ‘smart’ financial incentives on driving behaviour of novice drivers. / Mortimer, Duncan; Wijnands, Jasper S; Harris, Anthony; Tapp, Alan; Stevenson, Mark.

In: Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 119, 01.10.2018, p. 68-79.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - The effect of ‘smart’ financial incentives on driving behaviour of novice drivers

AU - Mortimer, Duncan

AU - Wijnands, Jasper S

AU - Harris, Anthony

AU - Tapp, Alan

AU - Stevenson, Mark

PY - 2018/10/1

Y1 - 2018/10/1

N2 - Recent studies have demonstrated that financial incentives can improve driving behaviour but high-value incentives are unlikely to be cost-effective and attempts to amplify the impact of low-value incentives have so far proven disappointing. The present study provides experimental evidence to inform the design of ‘smart’ and potentially more cost-effective incentives for safe driving in novice drivers. Study participants (n = 78) were randomised to one of four financial incentives: high-value penalty; low-value penalty; high-value reward; low-value reward; allowing us to compare high-value versus low-value incentives, penalties versus rewards, and to test specific hypotheses regarding motivational crowding out and gain/loss asymmetry. Results suggest that (i) penalties may be more effective than rewards of equal value, (ii) even low-value incentives can deliver net reductions in risky driving behaviours and, (iii) increasing the dollar-value of incentives may not increase their effectiveness. These design principles are currently being used to optimise the design of financial incentives embedded within PAYD insurance, with their impact on the driving behaviour of novice drivers to be evaluated in on-road trials.

AB - Recent studies have demonstrated that financial incentives can improve driving behaviour but high-value incentives are unlikely to be cost-effective and attempts to amplify the impact of low-value incentives have so far proven disappointing. The present study provides experimental evidence to inform the design of ‘smart’ and potentially more cost-effective incentives for safe driving in novice drivers. Study participants (n = 78) were randomised to one of four financial incentives: high-value penalty; low-value penalty; high-value reward; low-value reward; allowing us to compare high-value versus low-value incentives, penalties versus rewards, and to test specific hypotheses regarding motivational crowding out and gain/loss asymmetry. Results suggest that (i) penalties may be more effective than rewards of equal value, (ii) even low-value incentives can deliver net reductions in risky driving behaviours and, (iii) increasing the dollar-value of incentives may not increase their effectiveness. These design principles are currently being used to optimise the design of financial incentives embedded within PAYD insurance, with their impact on the driving behaviour of novice drivers to be evaluated in on-road trials.

KW - Behavioural economics

KW - Driving behaviour

KW - Financial incentives

KW - Road safety

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85049901710&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.aap.2018.06.014

DO - 10.1016/j.aap.2018.06.014

M3 - Article

VL - 119

SP - 68

EP - 79

JO - Accident Analysis and Prevention

JF - Accident Analysis and Prevention

SN - 0001-4575

ER -