Texts, Paratexts, and Contexts

A Comparative Study of English Translations of the Classic Chinese Novel Jin Ping Mei

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

This research project investigates the English translations and adaptations of the sixteenth-century classic Chinese novel Jin Ping Mei. Acclaimed the ‘No.1 Marvellous Book’ of the Ming dynasty, Jin Ping Mei was banned soon after its appearance, due to the inclusion of graphically explicit sexual descriptions. So far there have been more than a dozen English adaptations and translations of the novel. Working within the framework of Descriptive Translation Studies, this research provides a translational history of the English versions of Jin Ping Mei, supported by various paratexts, including book covers, reviews, and archival materials. The author also conducts textual comparisons to uncover the translation norms at work in each of the only two complete translations, namely The Golden Lotus by Clement Egerton and The Plum in the Golden Vase by David Tod Roy. The notions of agency, habitus and capital are introduced for the examination of the transference of linguistic, literary and cultural aspects of the two translations. This study is the first attempt to make systematic research on the English Translations of Jin Ping Mei. Given its pioneering status and interdisciplinary nature, the data, method and findings of this research project will potentially enrich the fields of Translation Studies, Comparative Literature, Chinese Studies, Cultural Studies and Book History.
Original languageEnglish
Article number3
Pages (from-to)29-51
Number of pages23
JournalDongfang fanyi (East Journal of Translation)
Volume2019
Publication statusPublished - May 2019

Keywords

  • Jin Ping Mei
  • English translation
  • censorship
  • literary classic
  • habitus
  • agent
  • David Roy
  • Clement Egerton
  • descriptive analysis

Cite this

@article{258d4d33828a4f14b308619c8106b5e9,
title = "Texts, Paratexts, and Contexts: A Comparative Study of English Translations of the Classic Chinese Novel Jin Ping Mei",
abstract = "This research project investigates the English translations and adaptations of the sixteenth-century classic Chinese novel Jin Ping Mei. Acclaimed the ‘No.1 Marvellous Book’ of the Ming dynasty, Jin Ping Mei was banned soon after its appearance, due to the inclusion of graphically explicit sexual descriptions. So far there have been more than a dozen English adaptations and translations of the novel. Working within the framework of Descriptive Translation Studies, this research provides a translational history of the English versions of Jin Ping Mei, supported by various paratexts, including book covers, reviews, and archival materials. The author also conducts textual comparisons to uncover the translation norms at work in each of the only two complete translations, namely The Golden Lotus by Clement Egerton and The Plum in the Golden Vase by David Tod Roy. The notions of agency, habitus and capital are introduced for the examination of the transference of linguistic, literary and cultural aspects of the two translations. This study is the first attempt to make systematic research on the English Translations of Jin Ping Mei. Given its pioneering status and interdisciplinary nature, the data, method and findings of this research project will potentially enrich the fields of Translation Studies, Comparative Literature, Chinese Studies, Cultural Studies and Book History.",
keywords = "Jin Ping Mei, English translation, censorship, literary classic, habitus, agent, David Roy, Clement Egerton, descriptive analysis",
author = "Rick Qi",
year = "2019",
month = "5",
language = "English",
volume = "2019",
pages = "29--51",
journal = "Dongfang fanyi (East Journal of Translation)",
issn = "1674-6686",

}

Texts, Paratexts, and Contexts : A Comparative Study of English Translations of the Classic Chinese Novel Jin Ping Mei. / Qi, Rick.

In: Dongfang fanyi (East Journal of Translation), Vol. 2019, 3, 05.2019, p. 29-51.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Texts, Paratexts, and Contexts

T2 - A Comparative Study of English Translations of the Classic Chinese Novel Jin Ping Mei

AU - Qi, Rick

PY - 2019/5

Y1 - 2019/5

N2 - This research project investigates the English translations and adaptations of the sixteenth-century classic Chinese novel Jin Ping Mei. Acclaimed the ‘No.1 Marvellous Book’ of the Ming dynasty, Jin Ping Mei was banned soon after its appearance, due to the inclusion of graphically explicit sexual descriptions. So far there have been more than a dozen English adaptations and translations of the novel. Working within the framework of Descriptive Translation Studies, this research provides a translational history of the English versions of Jin Ping Mei, supported by various paratexts, including book covers, reviews, and archival materials. The author also conducts textual comparisons to uncover the translation norms at work in each of the only two complete translations, namely The Golden Lotus by Clement Egerton and The Plum in the Golden Vase by David Tod Roy. The notions of agency, habitus and capital are introduced for the examination of the transference of linguistic, literary and cultural aspects of the two translations. This study is the first attempt to make systematic research on the English Translations of Jin Ping Mei. Given its pioneering status and interdisciplinary nature, the data, method and findings of this research project will potentially enrich the fields of Translation Studies, Comparative Literature, Chinese Studies, Cultural Studies and Book History.

AB - This research project investigates the English translations and adaptations of the sixteenth-century classic Chinese novel Jin Ping Mei. Acclaimed the ‘No.1 Marvellous Book’ of the Ming dynasty, Jin Ping Mei was banned soon after its appearance, due to the inclusion of graphically explicit sexual descriptions. So far there have been more than a dozen English adaptations and translations of the novel. Working within the framework of Descriptive Translation Studies, this research provides a translational history of the English versions of Jin Ping Mei, supported by various paratexts, including book covers, reviews, and archival materials. The author also conducts textual comparisons to uncover the translation norms at work in each of the only two complete translations, namely The Golden Lotus by Clement Egerton and The Plum in the Golden Vase by David Tod Roy. The notions of agency, habitus and capital are introduced for the examination of the transference of linguistic, literary and cultural aspects of the two translations. This study is the first attempt to make systematic research on the English Translations of Jin Ping Mei. Given its pioneering status and interdisciplinary nature, the data, method and findings of this research project will potentially enrich the fields of Translation Studies, Comparative Literature, Chinese Studies, Cultural Studies and Book History.

KW - Jin Ping Mei

KW - English translation

KW - censorship

KW - literary classic

KW - habitus

KW - agent

KW - David Roy

KW - Clement Egerton

KW - descriptive analysis

M3 - Article

VL - 2019

SP - 29

EP - 51

JO - Dongfang fanyi (East Journal of Translation)

JF - Dongfang fanyi (East Journal of Translation)

SN - 1674-6686

M1 - 3

ER -