TY - JOUR
T1 - Task-Shifting and Task-Sharing in Neurosurgery
T2 - An International Survey of Current Practices in Low- and Middle-Income Countries
AU - Robertson, Faith C.
AU - Esene, Ignatius N.
AU - Kolias, Angelos G.
AU - Kamalo, Patrick
AU - Fieggen, Graham
AU - Gormley, William B.
AU - Broekman, Marike L.D.
AU - Park, Kee B.
AU - Rosenfeld, Jeffrey
AU - Balak, Naci
AU - Ammar, Ahmed
AU - Tisel, Magnus
AU - Haglund, Michael
AU - Smith, Timothy
AU - Mendez, Ivar
AU - Brennum, Jannick
AU - Honeybul, Stephen
AU - Matsumara, Akira
AU - Muneza, Severien
AU - Rubiano, Andres
AU - Rosseau, Gail
AU - Khan, Tariq
AU - Misra, Basant
AU - Bolles, Gene
AU - Adelson, David
AU - Dempsey, Robert
AU - Hutchinson, Peter
AU - Aklilu, Abenezer
AU - Javier-Lizan, Abigail
AU - Belhachmi, Adil
AU - Khizar, Ahtesham
AU - Tascu, Alexandru
AU - Yalcinkaya, Ali
AU - Ndajiwo, Aliyu Baba
AU - Ukacjukwu, Alvan Emeka
AU - Agrawal, Amit
AU - Thapa, Amit
AU - Silva, Ana C.V.
AU - Gretschel, Armin
AU - Sukumaran, Arvind
AU - Vats, Atul
AU - Jarad, Bakr Abo
AU - Karmacharya, Balgopal
AU - Chaurasia, Bipin
AU - Liew, Boon Seng
AU - Rodriguez Arias, Carlos A.
AU - Karekezi, Claire
AU - Or, Cohen Inbar
AU - Sale, Danjuma
AU - Kanesen, Davendran
AU - Djilvesi, Djula
AU - Nwaribe, Evarsitus
AU - Mahmoud, M. Elhaj
AU - Awais, Mian
AU - Kumar, Sanjay
AU - Adeleye, Amos O.
AU - Agarwal, Manish
AU - Nkeshimana, Menelas
AU - Ndubuisi Achebe, Sunday David
AU - El Gaddafi, Walid
AU - Uysal, Ece
AU - Morgan, Eghosa
AU - Buno, Elubabor
AU - Sunday, Emmanuel
AU - Adefris, Esayas
AU - Alelyani, Fayez
AU - Constanzo, Felipe
AU - Longo, Gabriel
AU - Farooq, Ghulam
AU - Dunia, Goertz Mirenge
AU - Bot, Gyang Markus
AU - Shabani, Hamisi K.
AU - Deora, Harch
AU - Almenshawy, Hassan
AU - Kuheil, Hazem
AU - Maldonado, Igor Lima
AU - Negoi, Ionut
AU - Yousaf, Irfan
AU - Abdullah, Jafri Malin
AU - Golubovic, Jagos
AU - Ayadi, Khalil
AU - Limpastan, Kriengsak
AU - Jokonya, Luxwell
AU - Hodzic, Mirsad
AU - Kassem, Mohamed
AU - Al-Rawi, Mohammed
AU - Tariq, Muhammad
AU - Vyval, Mykola
AU - Abuhadrous, Nidal
AU - Syrmos, Nikolaos
AU - Alser, Osaid
AU - Young, Paul H.
AU - Wahjoepramono, Petra
AU - Sriram, Prabu Rau
AU - Ouchetati, Rafik
AU - Basaran, Recep
AU - Bhoot, Ritesh
AU - Amorim, Robson
AU - Ilić, Rosanda
AU - Wadanamby, Saman
AU - Fetene, Samuel M.
AU - Behari, Sanjay
AU - Babu, Satish
AU - Duong, Trung Kien
AU - Laeke, Tsegazeab
AU - Kanmounye, Ulrick S.
AU - Komar, Vladimir
AU - George, Ipe Vazheeparambil
AU - Hussain, Zahid
AU - Lucena, Lynne Lourdes N.
AU - Ekouele Mbaki, Hugues Brieux
AU - Kumwenda, Ken Keller
AU - Bah, Djvnaba
AU - Efe, Ibrahim E.
AU - Bandoh, Dickson
AU - Aji, Yunus Kuntawi
AU - Dakurah, Thomas
AU - Collaborative Working Group
N1 - Funding Information: A.G.K. is supported by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) Global Health Research Group on Neurotrauma. The Group was commissioned by the NIHR using Official Development Assistance funding (project 16/137/105). The views expressed in this article are those of the authors and are not necessarily those of the United Kingdom National Health Service, NIHR, or the United Kingdom Department of Health.
Publisher Copyright:
© 2019 The Authors
Copyright 2020 Elsevier B.V., All rights reserved.
PY - 2020/4
Y1 - 2020/4
N2 - Background: Because nearly 23,000 more neurosurgeons are needed globally to address 5 million essential neurosurgical cases that go untreated each year, there is an increasing interest in task-shifting and task-sharing (TS/S), delegating neurosurgical tasks to nonspecialists, particularly in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). This global survey aimed to provide a cross-sectional understanding of the prevalence and structure of current neurosurgical TS/S practices in LMICs. Methods: The survey was distributed to a convenience sample of individuals providing neurosurgical care in LMICs with a Web-based survey link via electronic mailing lists of continental societies and various neurosurgical groups, conference announcements, e-mailing lists, and social media platforms. Country-level data were analyzed by descriptive statistics. Results: The survey yielded 127 responses from 47 LMICs; 20 countries (42.6%) reported ongoing TS/S. Most TS/S procedures involved emergency interventions, the top 3 being burr holes, craniotomy for hematoma evacuation, and external ventricular drain. Most (65.0%) believed that their Ministry of Health does not endorse TS/S (24.0% unsure), and only 11% believed that TS/S training was structured. There were few opportunities for TS/S providers to continue medical education (11.6%) or maintenance of certification (9.4%, or receive remuneration (4.2%). Conclusions: TS/S is ongoing in many LMICs without substantial structure or oversight, which is concerning for patient safety. These data invite future clinical outcomes studies to assess effectiveness and discussions on policy recommendations such as standardized curricula, certification protocols, specialist oversight, and referral networks to increase the level of TS/S care and to continue to increase the specialist workforce.
AB - Background: Because nearly 23,000 more neurosurgeons are needed globally to address 5 million essential neurosurgical cases that go untreated each year, there is an increasing interest in task-shifting and task-sharing (TS/S), delegating neurosurgical tasks to nonspecialists, particularly in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). This global survey aimed to provide a cross-sectional understanding of the prevalence and structure of current neurosurgical TS/S practices in LMICs. Methods: The survey was distributed to a convenience sample of individuals providing neurosurgical care in LMICs with a Web-based survey link via electronic mailing lists of continental societies and various neurosurgical groups, conference announcements, e-mailing lists, and social media platforms. Country-level data were analyzed by descriptive statistics. Results: The survey yielded 127 responses from 47 LMICs; 20 countries (42.6%) reported ongoing TS/S. Most TS/S procedures involved emergency interventions, the top 3 being burr holes, craniotomy for hematoma evacuation, and external ventricular drain. Most (65.0%) believed that their Ministry of Health does not endorse TS/S (24.0% unsure), and only 11% believed that TS/S training was structured. There were few opportunities for TS/S providers to continue medical education (11.6%) or maintenance of certification (9.4%, or receive remuneration (4.2%). Conclusions: TS/S is ongoing in many LMICs without substantial structure or oversight, which is concerning for patient safety. These data invite future clinical outcomes studies to assess effectiveness and discussions on policy recommendations such as standardized curricula, certification protocols, specialist oversight, and referral networks to increase the level of TS/S care and to continue to increase the specialist workforce.
KW - Capacity
KW - Global health
KW - Global neurosurgery
KW - LMIC
KW - Task-sharing
KW - Task-shifting
KW - Workforce
UR - https://www.scopus.com/pages/publications/85073720240
U2 - 10.1016/j.wnsx.2019.100059
DO - 10.1016/j.wnsx.2019.100059
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85073720240
SN - 2590-1397
VL - 6
JO - World Neurosurgery: X
JF - World Neurosurgery: X
M1 - 100059
ER -