Target costing: First and second comings

Geoffrey Burrows, Robert Hunter Chenhall

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Contrary to the conventional wisdom that target costing (TC) was a 1960s Japanese innovation, it is argued that the same concept, albeit then labelled product tailoring , first appeared in the 1950s Anglophone managerial-economics literature in works linked to economist-consultant Joel Dean. These sources describe a range of North American applications of TC which clearly predate Japanese implementations. It is further argued that in the specifically accounting literature, Gordon Shillinglaw (1967) - a one-time employee of Dean - provided the first description of the TC concept. To support these propositions, the post-1990 TC literature is analysed to determine the key characteristics of TC. These phenomena are then shown to be present in the earlier works of Dean and his followers in an oeuvre which can be regarded as the first coming of the TC concept. The diffusion of TC concepts is then analysed from two perspectives: as between the USA and Japan at the enterprise level and within and between the economics and accounting literatures. Explanations are then offered for the diffusion patterns identified and for the neglect of the first-coming TC works.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)127 - 142
Number of pages16
JournalAccounting History Review
Volume22
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2012

Cite this

Burrows, Geoffrey ; Chenhall, Robert Hunter. / Target costing: First and second comings. In: Accounting History Review. 2012 ; Vol. 22, No. 2. pp. 127 - 142.
@article{b203c8159e284f9da135d22d9f49e9eb,
title = "Target costing: First and second comings",
abstract = "Contrary to the conventional wisdom that target costing (TC) was a 1960s Japanese innovation, it is argued that the same concept, albeit then labelled product tailoring , first appeared in the 1950s Anglophone managerial-economics literature in works linked to economist-consultant Joel Dean. These sources describe a range of North American applications of TC which clearly predate Japanese implementations. It is further argued that in the specifically accounting literature, Gordon Shillinglaw (1967) - a one-time employee of Dean - provided the first description of the TC concept. To support these propositions, the post-1990 TC literature is analysed to determine the key characteristics of TC. These phenomena are then shown to be present in the earlier works of Dean and his followers in an oeuvre which can be regarded as the first coming of the TC concept. The diffusion of TC concepts is then analysed from two perspectives: as between the USA and Japan at the enterprise level and within and between the economics and accounting literatures. Explanations are then offered for the diffusion patterns identified and for the neglect of the first-coming TC works.",
author = "Geoffrey Burrows and Chenhall, {Robert Hunter}",
year = "2012",
doi = "10.1080/21552851.2012.681124",
language = "English",
volume = "22",
pages = "127 -- 142",
journal = "Accounting History Review",
issn = "2155-2851",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",
number = "2",

}

Target costing: First and second comings. / Burrows, Geoffrey; Chenhall, Robert Hunter.

In: Accounting History Review, Vol. 22, No. 2, 2012, p. 127 - 142.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Target costing: First and second comings

AU - Burrows, Geoffrey

AU - Chenhall, Robert Hunter

PY - 2012

Y1 - 2012

N2 - Contrary to the conventional wisdom that target costing (TC) was a 1960s Japanese innovation, it is argued that the same concept, albeit then labelled product tailoring , first appeared in the 1950s Anglophone managerial-economics literature in works linked to economist-consultant Joel Dean. These sources describe a range of North American applications of TC which clearly predate Japanese implementations. It is further argued that in the specifically accounting literature, Gordon Shillinglaw (1967) - a one-time employee of Dean - provided the first description of the TC concept. To support these propositions, the post-1990 TC literature is analysed to determine the key characteristics of TC. These phenomena are then shown to be present in the earlier works of Dean and his followers in an oeuvre which can be regarded as the first coming of the TC concept. The diffusion of TC concepts is then analysed from two perspectives: as between the USA and Japan at the enterprise level and within and between the economics and accounting literatures. Explanations are then offered for the diffusion patterns identified and for the neglect of the first-coming TC works.

AB - Contrary to the conventional wisdom that target costing (TC) was a 1960s Japanese innovation, it is argued that the same concept, albeit then labelled product tailoring , first appeared in the 1950s Anglophone managerial-economics literature in works linked to economist-consultant Joel Dean. These sources describe a range of North American applications of TC which clearly predate Japanese implementations. It is further argued that in the specifically accounting literature, Gordon Shillinglaw (1967) - a one-time employee of Dean - provided the first description of the TC concept. To support these propositions, the post-1990 TC literature is analysed to determine the key characteristics of TC. These phenomena are then shown to be present in the earlier works of Dean and his followers in an oeuvre which can be regarded as the first coming of the TC concept. The diffusion of TC concepts is then analysed from two perspectives: as between the USA and Japan at the enterprise level and within and between the economics and accounting literatures. Explanations are then offered for the diffusion patterns identified and for the neglect of the first-coming TC works.

U2 - 10.1080/21552851.2012.681124

DO - 10.1080/21552851.2012.681124

M3 - Article

VL - 22

SP - 127

EP - 142

JO - Accounting History Review

JF - Accounting History Review

SN - 2155-2851

IS - 2

ER -