Print versus digital texts

Understanding the experimental research and challenging the dichotomies

Bella Ross, Ekaterina Pechenkina, Carol Aeschliman, Anne-Marie Chase

Research output: Contribution to journalReview ArticleResearchpeer-review

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This article presents the results of a systematic critical review of interdisciplinary literature concerned with digital text (or e-text) uses in education and proposes recommendations for how e-texts can be implemented for impactful learning. A variety of e-texts can be found in the repertoire of educational resources accessible to students, and in the constantly changing terrain of educational technologies, they are rapidly evolving, presenting new opportunities and affordances for student learning. We highlight some of the ways in which academic studies have examined e-texts as part of teaching and learning practices, placing a particular emphasis on aspects of learning such as recall, comprehension, retention of information and feedback. We also review diverse practices associated with uses of e-text tools such as note-taking, annotation, bookmarking, hypertexts and highlighting. We argue that evidence-based studies into e-texts are overwhelmingly structured around reinforcing the existing dichotomy pitting print- ased (‘traditional’) texts against e-texts. In this article, we query this approach and instead propose to focus on factors such as students’ level of awareness of their options in accessing learning materials and whether they are instructed and trained in how to take full advantage of the capabilities of e-texts, both of which have been found to affect learning performance.
Original languageEnglish
Number of pages12
JournalResearch in Learning Technology
Volume25
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2017

Keywords

  • Digital texts
  • e-texts
  • Electronic books
  • e-books
  • Comprehension
  • Recall
  • Professional development

Cite this

@article{1ce3e511d9f940c49a67280c79dcc612,
title = "Print versus digital texts: Understanding the experimental research and challenging the dichotomies",
abstract = "This article presents the results of a systematic critical review of interdisciplinary literature concerned with digital text (or e-text) uses in education and proposes recommendations for how e-texts can be implemented for impactful learning. A variety of e-texts can be found in the repertoire of educational resources accessible to students, and in the constantly changing terrain of educational technologies, they are rapidly evolving, presenting new opportunities and affordances for student learning. We highlight some of the ways in which academic studies have examined e-texts as part of teaching and learning practices, placing a particular emphasis on aspects of learning such as recall, comprehension, retention of information and feedback. We also review diverse practices associated with uses of e-text tools such as note-taking, annotation, bookmarking, hypertexts and highlighting. We argue that evidence-based studies into e-texts are overwhelmingly structured around reinforcing the existing dichotomy pitting print- ased (‘traditional’) texts against e-texts. In this article, we query this approach and instead propose to focus on factors such as students’ level of awareness of their options in accessing learning materials and whether they are instructed and trained in how to take full advantage of the capabilities of e-texts, both of which have been found to affect learning performance.",
keywords = "Digital texts, e-texts, Electronic books, e-books, Comprehension, Recall, Professional development",
author = "Bella Ross and Ekaterina Pechenkina and Carol Aeschliman and Anne-Marie Chase",
year = "2017",
doi = "10.25304/rlt.v25.1976",
language = "English",
volume = "25",
journal = "Research in Learning Technology",
issn = "2156-7069",
publisher = "Co-Action Publishing",

}

Print versus digital texts : Understanding the experimental research and challenging the dichotomies. / Ross, Bella; Pechenkina, Ekaterina; Aeschliman, Carol; Chase, Anne-Marie.

In: Research in Learning Technology, Vol. 25, 2017.

Research output: Contribution to journalReview ArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Print versus digital texts

T2 - Understanding the experimental research and challenging the dichotomies

AU - Ross, Bella

AU - Pechenkina, Ekaterina

AU - Aeschliman, Carol

AU - Chase, Anne-Marie

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - This article presents the results of a systematic critical review of interdisciplinary literature concerned with digital text (or e-text) uses in education and proposes recommendations for how e-texts can be implemented for impactful learning. A variety of e-texts can be found in the repertoire of educational resources accessible to students, and in the constantly changing terrain of educational technologies, they are rapidly evolving, presenting new opportunities and affordances for student learning. We highlight some of the ways in which academic studies have examined e-texts as part of teaching and learning practices, placing a particular emphasis on aspects of learning such as recall, comprehension, retention of information and feedback. We also review diverse practices associated with uses of e-text tools such as note-taking, annotation, bookmarking, hypertexts and highlighting. We argue that evidence-based studies into e-texts are overwhelmingly structured around reinforcing the existing dichotomy pitting print- ased (‘traditional’) texts against e-texts. In this article, we query this approach and instead propose to focus on factors such as students’ level of awareness of their options in accessing learning materials and whether they are instructed and trained in how to take full advantage of the capabilities of e-texts, both of which have been found to affect learning performance.

AB - This article presents the results of a systematic critical review of interdisciplinary literature concerned with digital text (or e-text) uses in education and proposes recommendations for how e-texts can be implemented for impactful learning. A variety of e-texts can be found in the repertoire of educational resources accessible to students, and in the constantly changing terrain of educational technologies, they are rapidly evolving, presenting new opportunities and affordances for student learning. We highlight some of the ways in which academic studies have examined e-texts as part of teaching and learning practices, placing a particular emphasis on aspects of learning such as recall, comprehension, retention of information and feedback. We also review diverse practices associated with uses of e-text tools such as note-taking, annotation, bookmarking, hypertexts and highlighting. We argue that evidence-based studies into e-texts are overwhelmingly structured around reinforcing the existing dichotomy pitting print- ased (‘traditional’) texts against e-texts. In this article, we query this approach and instead propose to focus on factors such as students’ level of awareness of their options in accessing learning materials and whether they are instructed and trained in how to take full advantage of the capabilities of e-texts, both of which have been found to affect learning performance.

KW - Digital texts

KW - e-texts

KW - Electronic books

KW - e-books

KW - Comprehension

KW - Recall

KW - Professional development

U2 - 10.25304/rlt.v25.1976

DO - 10.25304/rlt.v25.1976

M3 - Review Article

VL - 25

JO - Research in Learning Technology

JF - Research in Learning Technology

SN - 2156-7069

ER -