Papua New Guinea’s Extractive Resource Sector

Towards a Policy of Leaner Tax Incentives

Diane Kraal, Francis Odhuno

Research output: Book/ReportOther ReportResearch

Abstract

This paper reports on a review of tax incentives for the extractive resource sector in Papua New Guinea (PNG) to ascertain whether the incentives are economically beneficial for the country’s economy. A qualitative research approach was used that combined a triangulation of methods to compare tax incentive practices in PNG with that of Indonesia, Malaysia and Australia. A high level of discretion in providing tax incentives outside of legislation was evident in Indonesia and Malaysia, whereas legislated tax incentives for extractive industries are the norm in Australia. In contrast, the PNG government has, until now, provided ad hoc project-specific tax incentives to promote investment and distribute economic activity across the country. The country’s fiscal regime for the extractive sector is also not incorporated in general legislation. The paper explored whether tax incentives are linked to an increase in foreign direct investment (FDI), but no nexus was found between a high discretion for tax incentives and increased FDI. Due to the general lack of transparency in the PNG tax incentive system, it is not possible to ascertain the value of tax incentives. Indeed, given the absence of reliable reports of revenue loss on tax incentives, it is difficult to assess the merits of particular extractive sector tax incentives in the PNG context. PNG’s resource sector is the recipient of unnecessary additional tax incentives. Further support for this conclusion is the literature, which points to resource prospectivity, rather than tax incentives, as the primary motivator for FDI into the extractive industry. We recommend a policy program of leaner tax incentives for the extractive resource sector in PNG. An amendment to the Fiscal Responsibility Act 2006 is necessary for tax expenditure statements to be prepared outside of the national budget.
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationPapua New Guinea
PublisherThe National Research Institute Papua New Guinea
Number of pages53
ISBN (Print)9980752661
Publication statusPublished - Sep 2019

Publication series

NameThe National Research Institute Papua New Guinea Discussion Papers
No.172

Keywords

  • Taxation
  • Papua New Guinea
  • Mineral resources

Cite this

Kraal, D., & Odhuno, F. (2019). Papua New Guinea’s Extractive Resource Sector: Towards a Policy of Leaner Tax Incentives. (The National Research Institute Papua New Guinea Discussion Papers; No. 172). Papua New Guinea: The National Research Institute Papua New Guinea.
Kraal, Diane ; Odhuno, Francis . / Papua New Guinea’s Extractive Resource Sector : Towards a Policy of Leaner Tax Incentives. Papua New Guinea : The National Research Institute Papua New Guinea, 2019. 53 p. (The National Research Institute Papua New Guinea Discussion Papers; 172).
@book{ec62dd650d9e46deb0fc0f374a48f595,
title = "Papua New Guinea’s Extractive Resource Sector: Towards a Policy of Leaner Tax Incentives",
abstract = "This paper reports on a review of tax incentives for the extractive resource sector in Papua New Guinea (PNG) to ascertain whether the incentives are economically beneficial for the country’s economy. A qualitative research approach was used that combined a triangulation of methods to compare tax incentive practices in PNG with that of Indonesia, Malaysia and Australia. A high level of discretion in providing tax incentives outside of legislation was evident in Indonesia and Malaysia, whereas legislated tax incentives for extractive industries are the norm in Australia. In contrast, the PNG government has, until now, provided ad hoc project-specific tax incentives to promote investment and distribute economic activity across the country. The country’s fiscal regime for the extractive sector is also not incorporated in general legislation. The paper explored whether tax incentives are linked to an increase in foreign direct investment (FDI), but no nexus was found between a high discretion for tax incentives and increased FDI. Due to the general lack of transparency in the PNG tax incentive system, it is not possible to ascertain the value of tax incentives. Indeed, given the absence of reliable reports of revenue loss on tax incentives, it is difficult to assess the merits of particular extractive sector tax incentives in the PNG context. PNG’s resource sector is the recipient of unnecessary additional tax incentives. Further support for this conclusion is the literature, which points to resource prospectivity, rather than tax incentives, as the primary motivator for FDI into the extractive industry. We recommend a policy program of leaner tax incentives for the extractive resource sector in PNG. An amendment to the Fiscal Responsibility Act 2006 is necessary for tax expenditure statements to be prepared outside of the national budget.",
keywords = "Taxation, Papua New Guinea, Mineral resources",
author = "Diane Kraal and Francis Odhuno",
year = "2019",
month = "9",
language = "English",
isbn = "9980752661",
series = "The National Research Institute Papua New Guinea Discussion Papers",
publisher = "The National Research Institute Papua New Guinea",
number = "172",

}

Kraal, D & Odhuno, F 2019, Papua New Guinea’s Extractive Resource Sector: Towards a Policy of Leaner Tax Incentives. The National Research Institute Papua New Guinea Discussion Papers, no. 172, The National Research Institute Papua New Guinea, Papua New Guinea.

Papua New Guinea’s Extractive Resource Sector : Towards a Policy of Leaner Tax Incentives. / Kraal, Diane; Odhuno, Francis .

Papua New Guinea : The National Research Institute Papua New Guinea, 2019. 53 p. (The National Research Institute Papua New Guinea Discussion Papers; No. 172).

Research output: Book/ReportOther ReportResearch

TY - BOOK

T1 - Papua New Guinea’s Extractive Resource Sector

T2 - Towards a Policy of Leaner Tax Incentives

AU - Kraal, Diane

AU - Odhuno, Francis

PY - 2019/9

Y1 - 2019/9

N2 - This paper reports on a review of tax incentives for the extractive resource sector in Papua New Guinea (PNG) to ascertain whether the incentives are economically beneficial for the country’s economy. A qualitative research approach was used that combined a triangulation of methods to compare tax incentive practices in PNG with that of Indonesia, Malaysia and Australia. A high level of discretion in providing tax incentives outside of legislation was evident in Indonesia and Malaysia, whereas legislated tax incentives for extractive industries are the norm in Australia. In contrast, the PNG government has, until now, provided ad hoc project-specific tax incentives to promote investment and distribute economic activity across the country. The country’s fiscal regime for the extractive sector is also not incorporated in general legislation. The paper explored whether tax incentives are linked to an increase in foreign direct investment (FDI), but no nexus was found between a high discretion for tax incentives and increased FDI. Due to the general lack of transparency in the PNG tax incentive system, it is not possible to ascertain the value of tax incentives. Indeed, given the absence of reliable reports of revenue loss on tax incentives, it is difficult to assess the merits of particular extractive sector tax incentives in the PNG context. PNG’s resource sector is the recipient of unnecessary additional tax incentives. Further support for this conclusion is the literature, which points to resource prospectivity, rather than tax incentives, as the primary motivator for FDI into the extractive industry. We recommend a policy program of leaner tax incentives for the extractive resource sector in PNG. An amendment to the Fiscal Responsibility Act 2006 is necessary for tax expenditure statements to be prepared outside of the national budget.

AB - This paper reports on a review of tax incentives for the extractive resource sector in Papua New Guinea (PNG) to ascertain whether the incentives are economically beneficial for the country’s economy. A qualitative research approach was used that combined a triangulation of methods to compare tax incentive practices in PNG with that of Indonesia, Malaysia and Australia. A high level of discretion in providing tax incentives outside of legislation was evident in Indonesia and Malaysia, whereas legislated tax incentives for extractive industries are the norm in Australia. In contrast, the PNG government has, until now, provided ad hoc project-specific tax incentives to promote investment and distribute economic activity across the country. The country’s fiscal regime for the extractive sector is also not incorporated in general legislation. The paper explored whether tax incentives are linked to an increase in foreign direct investment (FDI), but no nexus was found between a high discretion for tax incentives and increased FDI. Due to the general lack of transparency in the PNG tax incentive system, it is not possible to ascertain the value of tax incentives. Indeed, given the absence of reliable reports of revenue loss on tax incentives, it is difficult to assess the merits of particular extractive sector tax incentives in the PNG context. PNG’s resource sector is the recipient of unnecessary additional tax incentives. Further support for this conclusion is the literature, which points to resource prospectivity, rather than tax incentives, as the primary motivator for FDI into the extractive industry. We recommend a policy program of leaner tax incentives for the extractive resource sector in PNG. An amendment to the Fiscal Responsibility Act 2006 is necessary for tax expenditure statements to be prepared outside of the national budget.

KW - Taxation

KW - Papua New Guinea

KW - Mineral resources

M3 - Other Report

SN - 9980752661

T3 - The National Research Institute Papua New Guinea Discussion Papers

BT - Papua New Guinea’s Extractive Resource Sector

PB - The National Research Institute Papua New Guinea

CY - Papua New Guinea

ER -

Kraal D, Odhuno F. Papua New Guinea’s Extractive Resource Sector: Towards a Policy of Leaner Tax Incentives. Papua New Guinea: The National Research Institute Papua New Guinea, 2019. 53 p. (The National Research Institute Papua New Guinea Discussion Papers; 172).