TY - JOUR
T1 - 'My child will never initiate ultimate harm'
T2 - An argument against moral enhancement
AU - Tonkens, Ryan Stewart
PY - 2015
Y1 - 2015
N2 - Recently, there has been a lot of philosophical work published on the morality of moral enhancement. One thing that tends to get overlooked in this literature is that there are many different potential methods of morally enhancing humans, and a blanket moral assessment of them may not be warranted. Here I focus on one mode of moral enhancement, namely, prenatal genetic moral enhancement, and offer a normative assessment of it. I argue that there is good reason to adopt a parentcentred perspective (as opposed to a social or statecentred perspective) towards the ethics of prenatal genetic moral enhancement, and, once we do so, that there is good reason to argue that prenatal genetic attempts at moral enhancement are morally problematic and ought not to be pursued. The main reasons for this have to do with the nature of moral enhancement research, and the idea that prospective parents are justified in not assuming that their children will be morally depraved. I leave it open as to whether other modes of morally enhancing humans fare better, morally speaking.
AB - Recently, there has been a lot of philosophical work published on the morality of moral enhancement. One thing that tends to get overlooked in this literature is that there are many different potential methods of morally enhancing humans, and a blanket moral assessment of them may not be warranted. Here I focus on one mode of moral enhancement, namely, prenatal genetic moral enhancement, and offer a normative assessment of it. I argue that there is good reason to adopt a parentcentred perspective (as opposed to a social or statecentred perspective) towards the ethics of prenatal genetic moral enhancement, and, once we do so, that there is good reason to argue that prenatal genetic attempts at moral enhancement are morally problematic and ought not to be pursued. The main reasons for this have to do with the nature of moral enhancement research, and the idea that prospective parents are justified in not assuming that their children will be morally depraved. I leave it open as to whether other modes of morally enhancing humans fare better, morally speaking.
UR - http://jme.bmj.com/content/41/3/245.full.pdf+html
UR - https://www.scopus.com/pages/publications/84923247711
U2 - 10.1136/medethics2013101855
DO - 10.1136/medethics2013101855
M3 - Article
SN - 0306-6800
VL - 41
SP - 245
EP - 251
JO - Journal of Medical Ethics
JF - Journal of Medical Ethics
IS - 3
ER -