Missing masculinities

gendering practices in Australian alcohol research and policy

David Moore, Suzanne Fraser, Helen Keane, Kate Seear, Kylie Valentine

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The issue of ‘alcohol-fuelled violence’ has been the subject of intense policy debate in Australia. While this debate is warranted, its contours and content have been informed and shaped by a surprisingly narrow range of research resources. Narrow research engagements of this kind warrant scrutiny because they can exclude from consideration crucial issues. In this article we identify one such issue, that of gender. Following a review of the Australian literature on gender, alcohol and violence, our analysis explores four case studies drawn from the Australian research corpus, focusing on large quantitative studies as these tend to receive most attention and citation in policy debate. Such studies consistently erase the contribution of key gender dynamics, namely enactments of particular (often youthful) masculinities, to violence involving alcohol, even where they simultaneously provide strong support in their data for such a conclusion. We show how this research is mobilised specifically in support of claims about the causal role of alcohol in violence and of blanket population-level responses to the problem. There is an urgent need to map the character and scope of the tendency to erase certain gender issues in research on alcohol and violence in order to better inform policy responses.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)309-324
Number of pages16
JournalAustralian Feminist Studies
Volume32
Issue number93
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 3 Jul 2017

Cite this

Moore, David ; Fraser, Suzanne ; Keane, Helen ; Seear, Kate ; Valentine, Kylie. / Missing masculinities : gendering practices in Australian alcohol research and policy. In: Australian Feminist Studies. 2017 ; Vol. 32, No. 93. pp. 309-324.
@article{af64c0b79f3b4c9daa32b3ad05029a01,
title = "Missing masculinities: gendering practices in Australian alcohol research and policy",
abstract = "The issue of ‘alcohol-fuelled violence’ has been the subject of intense policy debate in Australia. While this debate is warranted, its contours and content have been informed and shaped by a surprisingly narrow range of research resources. Narrow research engagements of this kind warrant scrutiny because they can exclude from consideration crucial issues. In this article we identify one such issue, that of gender. Following a review of the Australian literature on gender, alcohol and violence, our analysis explores four case studies drawn from the Australian research corpus, focusing on large quantitative studies as these tend to receive most attention and citation in policy debate. Such studies consistently erase the contribution of key gender dynamics, namely enactments of particular (often youthful) masculinities, to violence involving alcohol, even where they simultaneously provide strong support in their data for such a conclusion. We show how this research is mobilised specifically in support of claims about the causal role of alcohol in violence and of blanket population-level responses to the problem. There is an urgent need to map the character and scope of the tendency to erase certain gender issues in research on alcohol and violence in order to better inform policy responses.",
author = "David Moore and Suzanne Fraser and Helen Keane and Kate Seear and Kylie Valentine",
year = "2017",
month = "7",
day = "3",
doi = "10.1080/08164649.2017.1407639",
language = "English",
volume = "32",
pages = "309--324",
journal = "Australian Feminist Studies",
issn = "0816-4649",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",
number = "93",

}

Missing masculinities : gendering practices in Australian alcohol research and policy. / Moore, David; Fraser, Suzanne; Keane, Helen; Seear, Kate; Valentine, Kylie.

In: Australian Feminist Studies, Vol. 32, No. 93, 03.07.2017, p. 309-324.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Missing masculinities

T2 - gendering practices in Australian alcohol research and policy

AU - Moore, David

AU - Fraser, Suzanne

AU - Keane, Helen

AU - Seear, Kate

AU - Valentine, Kylie

PY - 2017/7/3

Y1 - 2017/7/3

N2 - The issue of ‘alcohol-fuelled violence’ has been the subject of intense policy debate in Australia. While this debate is warranted, its contours and content have been informed and shaped by a surprisingly narrow range of research resources. Narrow research engagements of this kind warrant scrutiny because they can exclude from consideration crucial issues. In this article we identify one such issue, that of gender. Following a review of the Australian literature on gender, alcohol and violence, our analysis explores four case studies drawn from the Australian research corpus, focusing on large quantitative studies as these tend to receive most attention and citation in policy debate. Such studies consistently erase the contribution of key gender dynamics, namely enactments of particular (often youthful) masculinities, to violence involving alcohol, even where they simultaneously provide strong support in their data for such a conclusion. We show how this research is mobilised specifically in support of claims about the causal role of alcohol in violence and of blanket population-level responses to the problem. There is an urgent need to map the character and scope of the tendency to erase certain gender issues in research on alcohol and violence in order to better inform policy responses.

AB - The issue of ‘alcohol-fuelled violence’ has been the subject of intense policy debate in Australia. While this debate is warranted, its contours and content have been informed and shaped by a surprisingly narrow range of research resources. Narrow research engagements of this kind warrant scrutiny because they can exclude from consideration crucial issues. In this article we identify one such issue, that of gender. Following a review of the Australian literature on gender, alcohol and violence, our analysis explores four case studies drawn from the Australian research corpus, focusing on large quantitative studies as these tend to receive most attention and citation in policy debate. Such studies consistently erase the contribution of key gender dynamics, namely enactments of particular (often youthful) masculinities, to violence involving alcohol, even where they simultaneously provide strong support in their data for such a conclusion. We show how this research is mobilised specifically in support of claims about the causal role of alcohol in violence and of blanket population-level responses to the problem. There is an urgent need to map the character and scope of the tendency to erase certain gender issues in research on alcohol and violence in order to better inform policy responses.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85038412676&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/08164649.2017.1407639

DO - 10.1080/08164649.2017.1407639

M3 - Article

VL - 32

SP - 309

EP - 324

JO - Australian Feminist Studies

JF - Australian Feminist Studies

SN - 0816-4649

IS - 93

ER -