Maps Made by Temperance: The Legacy of 'Local Option' Controls on Alcohol in Melbourne

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference PaperResearchpeer-review

Abstract

When Melbourne’s two ‘dry zones’ had compulsory ballots for restaurant and café liquor licences removed in 2015, news accounts surmised that “a hangover from the anti-alcohol movement of the 1920s had finally been relegated to the history books”. Yet the dry zones are chapters in a longer, ongoing story. The 1920 poll that created these anachronistic alcohol-free pockets culminated half
a century of campaigns in Australia and beyond for local alcohol controls, prohibitions and vetos including ‘local option’. This paper looks specifically at temperance era local-level politics, and its legacies for cities like Melbourne today. The paper uses archival records and historical GIS techniques to show the workings and debates of Victoria’s early local option policies, and their
corollaries statutory limits and dry zones – some of which survive residually today. Mapping the rise and spatial impacts of local policies on hotel numbers it shows the temperance movement of the late 19th century using nascent planning laws to legitimise local popular political power, and the control not only of alcohol but of land use and disorder more broadly. Drawing on the idea of genealogies of planning (Booth 2005) the paper argues local option history has legacies for, and parallels with, questions facing cities and planning today. As some temperance-era controls are being wound back, essentially identical policies are being reasserted.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationRemaking Cities: Urban History Planning History Conference Proceedings
EditorsIan McShane, Elizabeth Taylor, Libby Porter, Ian Woodcock
Place of PublicationMelbourne, Vic, Australia
PublisherAustralasian Urban History Planning History Group and the RMIT Centre for Urban Research
Pages493-506
Number of pages14
ISBN (Print)978-0-9953791-1-4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2018
Externally publishedYes
EventAustralasian Urban History Planning History Conference 2018 - Centre for Urban Research, Melbourne, Australia
Duration: 31 Jan 20182 Feb 2018

Conference

ConferenceAustralasian Urban History Planning History Conference 2018
CountryAustralia
CityMelbourne
Period31/01/182/02/18

Keywords

  • Melbourne
  • dry-zone
  • alcohol
  • planning laws

Cite this

Taylor, E. J. (2018). Maps Made by Temperance: The Legacy of 'Local Option' Controls on Alcohol in Melbourne. In I. McShane, E. Taylor, L. Porter, & I. Woodcock (Eds.), Remaking Cities: Urban History Planning History Conference Proceedings (pp. 493-506). Melbourne, Vic, Australia: Australasian Urban History Planning History Group and the RMIT Centre for Urban Research. https://doi.org//10.25916/5c2469d75e7b5
Taylor, Elizabeth Jean. / Maps Made by Temperance: The Legacy of 'Local Option' Controls on Alcohol in Melbourne. Remaking Cities: Urban History Planning History Conference Proceedings. editor / Ian McShane ; Elizabeth Taylor ; Libby Porter ; Ian Woodcock. Melbourne, Vic, Australia : Australasian Urban History Planning History Group and the RMIT Centre for Urban Research, 2018. pp. 493-506
@inproceedings{c2bc4f61dce1471084e14cf9f61df8e7,
title = "Maps Made by Temperance: The Legacy of 'Local Option' Controls on Alcohol in Melbourne",
abstract = "When Melbourne’s two ‘dry zones’ had compulsory ballots for restaurant and caf{\'e} liquor licences removed in 2015, news accounts surmised that “a hangover from the anti-alcohol movement of the 1920s had finally been relegated to the history books”. Yet the dry zones are chapters in a longer, ongoing story. The 1920 poll that created these anachronistic alcohol-free pockets culminated halfa century of campaigns in Australia and beyond for local alcohol controls, prohibitions and vetos including ‘local option’. This paper looks specifically at temperance era local-level politics, and its legacies for cities like Melbourne today. The paper uses archival records and historical GIS techniques to show the workings and debates of Victoria’s early local option policies, and theircorollaries statutory limits and dry zones – some of which survive residually today. Mapping the rise and spatial impacts of local policies on hotel numbers it shows the temperance movement of the late 19th century using nascent planning laws to legitimise local popular political power, and the control not only of alcohol but of land use and disorder more broadly. Drawing on the idea of genealogies of planning (Booth 2005) the paper argues local option history has legacies for, and parallels with, questions facing cities and planning today. As some temperance-era controls are being wound back, essentially identical policies are being reasserted.",
keywords = "Melbourne, dry-zone, alcohol, planning laws",
author = "Taylor, {Elizabeth Jean}",
year = "2018",
doi = "/10.25916/5c2469d75e7b5",
language = "English",
isbn = "978-0-9953791-1-4",
pages = "493--506",
editor = "Ian McShane and Elizabeth Taylor and Libby Porter and Ian Woodcock",
booktitle = "Remaking Cities: Urban History Planning History Conference Proceedings",
publisher = "Australasian Urban History Planning History Group and the RMIT Centre for Urban Research",

}

Taylor, EJ 2018, Maps Made by Temperance: The Legacy of 'Local Option' Controls on Alcohol in Melbourne. in I McShane, E Taylor, L Porter & I Woodcock (eds), Remaking Cities: Urban History Planning History Conference Proceedings. Australasian Urban History Planning History Group and the RMIT Centre for Urban Research, Melbourne, Vic, Australia, pp. 493-506, Australasian Urban History Planning History Conference 2018, Melbourne, Australia, 31/01/18. https://doi.org//10.25916/5c2469d75e7b5

Maps Made by Temperance: The Legacy of 'Local Option' Controls on Alcohol in Melbourne. / Taylor, Elizabeth Jean.

Remaking Cities: Urban History Planning History Conference Proceedings. ed. / Ian McShane; Elizabeth Taylor; Libby Porter; Ian Woodcock. Melbourne, Vic, Australia : Australasian Urban History Planning History Group and the RMIT Centre for Urban Research, 2018. p. 493-506.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference PaperResearchpeer-review

TY - GEN

T1 - Maps Made by Temperance: The Legacy of 'Local Option' Controls on Alcohol in Melbourne

AU - Taylor, Elizabeth Jean

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - When Melbourne’s two ‘dry zones’ had compulsory ballots for restaurant and café liquor licences removed in 2015, news accounts surmised that “a hangover from the anti-alcohol movement of the 1920s had finally been relegated to the history books”. Yet the dry zones are chapters in a longer, ongoing story. The 1920 poll that created these anachronistic alcohol-free pockets culminated halfa century of campaigns in Australia and beyond for local alcohol controls, prohibitions and vetos including ‘local option’. This paper looks specifically at temperance era local-level politics, and its legacies for cities like Melbourne today. The paper uses archival records and historical GIS techniques to show the workings and debates of Victoria’s early local option policies, and theircorollaries statutory limits and dry zones – some of which survive residually today. Mapping the rise and spatial impacts of local policies on hotel numbers it shows the temperance movement of the late 19th century using nascent planning laws to legitimise local popular political power, and the control not only of alcohol but of land use and disorder more broadly. Drawing on the idea of genealogies of planning (Booth 2005) the paper argues local option history has legacies for, and parallels with, questions facing cities and planning today. As some temperance-era controls are being wound back, essentially identical policies are being reasserted.

AB - When Melbourne’s two ‘dry zones’ had compulsory ballots for restaurant and café liquor licences removed in 2015, news accounts surmised that “a hangover from the anti-alcohol movement of the 1920s had finally been relegated to the history books”. Yet the dry zones are chapters in a longer, ongoing story. The 1920 poll that created these anachronistic alcohol-free pockets culminated halfa century of campaigns in Australia and beyond for local alcohol controls, prohibitions and vetos including ‘local option’. This paper looks specifically at temperance era local-level politics, and its legacies for cities like Melbourne today. The paper uses archival records and historical GIS techniques to show the workings and debates of Victoria’s early local option policies, and theircorollaries statutory limits and dry zones – some of which survive residually today. Mapping the rise and spatial impacts of local policies on hotel numbers it shows the temperance movement of the late 19th century using nascent planning laws to legitimise local popular political power, and the control not only of alcohol but of land use and disorder more broadly. Drawing on the idea of genealogies of planning (Booth 2005) the paper argues local option history has legacies for, and parallels with, questions facing cities and planning today. As some temperance-era controls are being wound back, essentially identical policies are being reasserted.

KW - Melbourne

KW - dry-zone

KW - alcohol

KW - planning laws

U2 - /10.25916/5c2469d75e7b5

DO - /10.25916/5c2469d75e7b5

M3 - Conference Paper

SN - 978-0-9953791-1-4

SP - 493

EP - 506

BT - Remaking Cities: Urban History Planning History Conference Proceedings

A2 - McShane, Ian

A2 - Taylor, Elizabeth

A2 - Porter, Libby

A2 - Woodcock, Ian

PB - Australasian Urban History Planning History Group and the RMIT Centre for Urban Research

CY - Melbourne, Vic, Australia

ER -

Taylor EJ. Maps Made by Temperance: The Legacy of 'Local Option' Controls on Alcohol in Melbourne. In McShane I, Taylor E, Porter L, Woodcock I, editors, Remaking Cities: Urban History Planning History Conference Proceedings. Melbourne, Vic, Australia: Australasian Urban History Planning History Group and the RMIT Centre for Urban Research. 2018. p. 493-506 https://doi.org//10.25916/5c2469d75e7b5