TY - JOUR
T1 - La verdad es lo que el contexto hace de ella
AU - Allan, Keith
N1 - Funding Information:
I am very grateful to have been invited to participate in the monographic volume Philosophy of what we must pass over in silence. Central topics of Philosophy of Language in homage to Pedro Chamizo. For about two decades I have very much enjoyed interactions in person and electronically with Pedro Chamizo Domínguez whose scholarship and character I revere. I also wish to thank the reviewers of my essay for their helpful and insightful comments. All remaining faults are my responsibility alone.
Publisher Copyright:
© 2022 Universidad de Malaga. All right reserved.
PY - 2022
Y1 - 2022
N2 - This essay shows that truth cannot be divorced from human experience and an individual’s world view, his or her weltanschauung. There exist different weltanschauungen that favour alternative truths. Thus, loosely speaking, truth is determined by context. It may be socially acceptable to prefer one among the alternative truths as truly true, but this goal necessarily involves taking an ideological perspective on what is perceived and accepted as the sole truth. In other words, it is prejudiced. The truth value assigned to the proposition God exists starkly illustrates this claim, but in the course of this essay I demonstrate that alternative truths are widespread and that conflicting truths can co-exist within a community even when they create dissension. A hegemonic group will assert a preference for one truth over its alternatives, but that does not eliminate the existence of alternative truths. Alternative weltanschauungen need to be managed somehow, and the recognition that alternative truths exist is one step in their management.
AB - This essay shows that truth cannot be divorced from human experience and an individual’s world view, his or her weltanschauung. There exist different weltanschauungen that favour alternative truths. Thus, loosely speaking, truth is determined by context. It may be socially acceptable to prefer one among the alternative truths as truly true, but this goal necessarily involves taking an ideological perspective on what is perceived and accepted as the sole truth. In other words, it is prejudiced. The truth value assigned to the proposition God exists starkly illustrates this claim, but in the course of this essay I demonstrate that alternative truths are widespread and that conflicting truths can co-exist within a community even when they create dissension. A hegemonic group will assert a preference for one truth over its alternatives, but that does not eliminate the existence of alternative truths. Alternative weltanschauungen need to be managed somehow, and the recognition that alternative truths exist is one step in their management.
KW - ALTERNATIVE TRUTHS
KW - CONTEXT
KW - FUZZY TRUTH
KW - IDEOLOGIES
KW - INCONTROVERTIBLE TRUTHS
KW - WELTANSCHAUUNGEN
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85146169837&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.24310/Claridadescrf.v14i2.13620
DO - 10.24310/Claridadescrf.v14i2.13620
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85146169837
SN - 1889-6855
VL - 14
SP - 15
EP - 33
JO - Claridades
JF - Claridades
IS - 2
ER -