How do Jewish communities respond to manifestations of institutional child sexual abuse?

A case study of Malka Leifer and Adass Israel in Melbourne, Australia

Philip Mendes, Marcia Pinskier, Samone McCurdy

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleOtherpeer-review

Abstract

The recent Australian Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse provided some insight into manifestations of child sexual abuse within an ultra-orthodox Jewish community. This paper extends the analysis by the Royal Commission (RC) to another Australian ultra-orthodox community that of Adass Israel, whereby a former school headmistress allegedly abused multiple students and then fled to the State of Israel in 2008. That case is unusual given that both the perpetrator and victims were female. Attention is drawn to a number of components similar to the RC findings pertaining to the particular vulnerability of children within ultra-orthodox communities given the absence of sex education and entrenched patriarchal authority, the reluctance of such communities to report child sexual abuse (CSA) allegations to secular authorities and associated cultural and religious factors, the failure of community leaders within or beyond Australia to support or compensate CSA survivors, and the absence of formal child protection protocols. Additionally, some conclusions are drawn about the key role played by advocacy groups such as Jewish Community Watch in exposing the global travel of child sex offenders, and the problematic legal protection provided to many such offenders by the State of Israel’s Law of Return.

Original languageEnglish
Number of pages18
JournalJournal of Child Sexual Abuse
DOIs
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 17 Sep 2019

Keywords

  • child protection
  • Child sexual abuse
  • patriarchy
  • ultra-orthodox Jews

Cite this

@article{bd0f1bd57318471286d8c39cf15eead5,
title = "How do Jewish communities respond to manifestations of institutional child sexual abuse?: A case study of Malka Leifer and Adass Israel in Melbourne, Australia",
abstract = "The recent Australian Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse provided some insight into manifestations of child sexual abuse within an ultra-orthodox Jewish community. This paper extends the analysis by the Royal Commission (RC) to another Australian ultra-orthodox community that of Adass Israel, whereby a former school headmistress allegedly abused multiple students and then fled to the State of Israel in 2008. That case is unusual given that both the perpetrator and victims were female. Attention is drawn to a number of components similar to the RC findings pertaining to the particular vulnerability of children within ultra-orthodox communities given the absence of sex education and entrenched patriarchal authority, the reluctance of such communities to report child sexual abuse (CSA) allegations to secular authorities and associated cultural and religious factors, the failure of community leaders within or beyond Australia to support or compensate CSA survivors, and the absence of formal child protection protocols. Additionally, some conclusions are drawn about the key role played by advocacy groups such as Jewish Community Watch in exposing the global travel of child sex offenders, and the problematic legal protection provided to many such offenders by the State of Israel’s Law of Return.",
keywords = "child protection, Child sexual abuse, patriarchy, ultra-orthodox Jews",
author = "Philip Mendes and Marcia Pinskier and Samone McCurdy",
year = "2019",
month = "9",
day = "17",
doi = "10.1080/10538712.2019.1675842",
language = "English",
journal = "Journal of Child Sexual Abuse",
issn = "1053-8712",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - How do Jewish communities respond to manifestations of institutional child sexual abuse?

T2 - A case study of Malka Leifer and Adass Israel in Melbourne, Australia

AU - Mendes, Philip

AU - Pinskier, Marcia

AU - McCurdy, Samone

PY - 2019/9/17

Y1 - 2019/9/17

N2 - The recent Australian Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse provided some insight into manifestations of child sexual abuse within an ultra-orthodox Jewish community. This paper extends the analysis by the Royal Commission (RC) to another Australian ultra-orthodox community that of Adass Israel, whereby a former school headmistress allegedly abused multiple students and then fled to the State of Israel in 2008. That case is unusual given that both the perpetrator and victims were female. Attention is drawn to a number of components similar to the RC findings pertaining to the particular vulnerability of children within ultra-orthodox communities given the absence of sex education and entrenched patriarchal authority, the reluctance of such communities to report child sexual abuse (CSA) allegations to secular authorities and associated cultural and religious factors, the failure of community leaders within or beyond Australia to support or compensate CSA survivors, and the absence of formal child protection protocols. Additionally, some conclusions are drawn about the key role played by advocacy groups such as Jewish Community Watch in exposing the global travel of child sex offenders, and the problematic legal protection provided to many such offenders by the State of Israel’s Law of Return.

AB - The recent Australian Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse provided some insight into manifestations of child sexual abuse within an ultra-orthodox Jewish community. This paper extends the analysis by the Royal Commission (RC) to another Australian ultra-orthodox community that of Adass Israel, whereby a former school headmistress allegedly abused multiple students and then fled to the State of Israel in 2008. That case is unusual given that both the perpetrator and victims were female. Attention is drawn to a number of components similar to the RC findings pertaining to the particular vulnerability of children within ultra-orthodox communities given the absence of sex education and entrenched patriarchal authority, the reluctance of such communities to report child sexual abuse (CSA) allegations to secular authorities and associated cultural and religious factors, the failure of community leaders within or beyond Australia to support or compensate CSA survivors, and the absence of formal child protection protocols. Additionally, some conclusions are drawn about the key role played by advocacy groups such as Jewish Community Watch in exposing the global travel of child sex offenders, and the problematic legal protection provided to many such offenders by the State of Israel’s Law of Return.

KW - child protection

KW - Child sexual abuse

KW - patriarchy

KW - ultra-orthodox Jews

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85074376612&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/10538712.2019.1675842

DO - 10.1080/10538712.2019.1675842

M3 - Article

JO - Journal of Child Sexual Abuse

JF - Journal of Child Sexual Abuse

SN - 1053-8712

ER -