Figuring out the prevalence of fitness testing in physical education: a figurational analysis

Laura Alfrey, Michael Gard

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

This paper explores the ways in which figurational sociology can offer a useful lens through which to understand the ongoing use of fitness testing as a means to physically educate young people. We contribute to a theoretical discussion around how physical education teachers have come to think about and enact fitness testing so pervasively. Applying a figurational lens: (a) encourages us to view fitness testing as a historically rooted practice; (b) sensitises us to the importance of social interdependencies and habitus when trying to understand their prevalence; (c) helps us to go beyond the labelling of fitness testing as ‘disciplinary’ and encourages us to identify the (un)intended consequences of fitness testing, and how these are enabling and constraining and for whom. Using a figurational lens we identify scientisation and shaming as two social processes that can help us understand why physical educators use fitness testing as a context for learning despite a lack of evidence to suggest its worth. The theorising articulated in this paper, together with the sociological work it follows, can help us move forward in terms of pedagogical possibilities for physical education.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)187-202
Number of pages16
JournalEuropean Physical Education Review
Volume25
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2019

Keywords

  • physical education
  • teachers
  • fitness testing
  • figurational sociology
  • Elias

Cite this

@article{dd1a8a6763ac41c8930dc93fa814b950,
title = "Figuring out the prevalence of fitness testing in physical education: a figurational analysis",
abstract = "This paper explores the ways in which figurational sociology can offer a useful lens through which to understand the ongoing use of fitness testing as a means to physically educate young people. We contribute to a theoretical discussion around how physical education teachers have come to think about and enact fitness testing so pervasively. Applying a figurational lens: (a) encourages us to view fitness testing as a historically rooted practice; (b) sensitises us to the importance of social interdependencies and habitus when trying to understand their prevalence; (c) helps us to go beyond the labelling of fitness testing as ‘disciplinary’ and encourages us to identify the (un)intended consequences of fitness testing, and how these are enabling and constraining and for whom. Using a figurational lens we identify scientisation and shaming as two social processes that can help us understand why physical educators use fitness testing as a context for learning despite a lack of evidence to suggest its worth. The theorising articulated in this paper, together with the sociological work it follows, can help us move forward in terms of pedagogical possibilities for physical education.",
keywords = "physical education, teachers, fitness testing, figurational sociology, Elias",
author = "Laura Alfrey and Michael Gard",
year = "2019",
doi = "10.1177/1356336X17715361",
language = "English",
volume = "25",
pages = "187--202",
journal = "European Physical Education Review",
issn = "1356-336X",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd",
number = "1",

}

Figuring out the prevalence of fitness testing in physical education : a figurational analysis. / Alfrey, Laura; Gard, Michael.

In: European Physical Education Review, Vol. 25, No. 1, 2019, p. 187-202.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Figuring out the prevalence of fitness testing in physical education

T2 - a figurational analysis

AU - Alfrey, Laura

AU - Gard, Michael

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - This paper explores the ways in which figurational sociology can offer a useful lens through which to understand the ongoing use of fitness testing as a means to physically educate young people. We contribute to a theoretical discussion around how physical education teachers have come to think about and enact fitness testing so pervasively. Applying a figurational lens: (a) encourages us to view fitness testing as a historically rooted practice; (b) sensitises us to the importance of social interdependencies and habitus when trying to understand their prevalence; (c) helps us to go beyond the labelling of fitness testing as ‘disciplinary’ and encourages us to identify the (un)intended consequences of fitness testing, and how these are enabling and constraining and for whom. Using a figurational lens we identify scientisation and shaming as two social processes that can help us understand why physical educators use fitness testing as a context for learning despite a lack of evidence to suggest its worth. The theorising articulated in this paper, together with the sociological work it follows, can help us move forward in terms of pedagogical possibilities for physical education.

AB - This paper explores the ways in which figurational sociology can offer a useful lens through which to understand the ongoing use of fitness testing as a means to physically educate young people. We contribute to a theoretical discussion around how physical education teachers have come to think about and enact fitness testing so pervasively. Applying a figurational lens: (a) encourages us to view fitness testing as a historically rooted practice; (b) sensitises us to the importance of social interdependencies and habitus when trying to understand their prevalence; (c) helps us to go beyond the labelling of fitness testing as ‘disciplinary’ and encourages us to identify the (un)intended consequences of fitness testing, and how these are enabling and constraining and for whom. Using a figurational lens we identify scientisation and shaming as two social processes that can help us understand why physical educators use fitness testing as a context for learning despite a lack of evidence to suggest its worth. The theorising articulated in this paper, together with the sociological work it follows, can help us move forward in terms of pedagogical possibilities for physical education.

KW - physical education

KW - teachers

KW - fitness testing

KW - figurational sociology

KW - Elias

U2 - 10.1177/1356336X17715361

DO - 10.1177/1356336X17715361

M3 - Article

VL - 25

SP - 187

EP - 202

JO - European Physical Education Review

JF - European Physical Education Review

SN - 1356-336X

IS - 1

ER -