Examining the interpersonal process and consequence of leader-member exchange comparison

the role of procedural justice climate

Herman H.M. Tse, Catherine K. Lam, Jun Gu, Xiao Song Lin

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Individuals are always sensitive to their relative standing in interpersonal comparison processes of leader-member exchanges (LMXs) in teams. Little research, however, has investigated whether coworkers with a higher LMX influence the emotional and behavioral reactions of individuals with a lower LMX in different dyads. Drawing on social comparison theory and the symbolic model of procedural justice (PJ) climate, we conducted 2 independent studies-an experimental study focusing on the self-perceived upward LMX comparison (i.e., an individual perceives that a coworker's LMX is higher than the LMX that he or she has with the supervisor; N = 203; Study 1: American working adults) and a field survey study focusing on the other-perceived downward LMX comparison (i.e., a coworker perceives that his or her own LMX is higher than the LMX that the individual has with the supervisor; N = 177; Study 2: Chinese software engineers). Results from these studies consistently revealed that a coworker's higher LMX elicits an individual's hostile emotions when the PJ climate is low but that this relationship is buffered when the PJ climate is high. Results of both studies also showed that the coworker's higher LMX arouses the individual to direct harmful behavior toward that coworker (via the individual's feelings of hostility) when the PJ climate is low but not when it is high.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)922-940
Number of pages19
JournalJournal of Organizational Behavior
Volume39
Issue number8
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2018

Keywords

  • Coworker dyads
  • Interpersonal hostility and harming
  • Leader-member exchange (LMX) comparison
  • Procedural justice climate

Cite this

@article{917c24f024ca49e58f32671a533266fc,
title = "Examining the interpersonal process and consequence of leader-member exchange comparison: the role of procedural justice climate",
abstract = "Individuals are always sensitive to their relative standing in interpersonal comparison processes of leader-member exchanges (LMXs) in teams. Little research, however, has investigated whether coworkers with a higher LMX influence the emotional and behavioral reactions of individuals with a lower LMX in different dyads. Drawing on social comparison theory and the symbolic model of procedural justice (PJ) climate, we conducted 2 independent studies-an experimental study focusing on the self-perceived upward LMX comparison (i.e., an individual perceives that a coworker's LMX is higher than the LMX that he or she has with the supervisor; N = 203; Study 1: American working adults) and a field survey study focusing on the other-perceived downward LMX comparison (i.e., a coworker perceives that his or her own LMX is higher than the LMX that the individual has with the supervisor; N = 177; Study 2: Chinese software engineers). Results from these studies consistently revealed that a coworker's higher LMX elicits an individual's hostile emotions when the PJ climate is low but that this relationship is buffered when the PJ climate is high. Results of both studies also showed that the coworker's higher LMX arouses the individual to direct harmful behavior toward that coworker (via the individual's feelings of hostility) when the PJ climate is low but not when it is high.",
keywords = "Coworker dyads, Interpersonal hostility and harming, Leader-member exchange (LMX) comparison, Procedural justice climate",
author = "Tse, {Herman H.M.} and Lam, {Catherine K.} and Jun Gu and Lin, {Xiao Song}",
year = "2018",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1002/job.2268",
language = "English",
volume = "39",
pages = "922--940",
journal = "Journal of Organizational Behavior",
issn = "0894-3796",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "8",

}

Examining the interpersonal process and consequence of leader-member exchange comparison : the role of procedural justice climate. / Tse, Herman H.M.; Lam, Catherine K.; Gu, Jun; Lin, Xiao Song.

In: Journal of Organizational Behavior, Vol. 39, No. 8, 10.2018, p. 922-940.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Examining the interpersonal process and consequence of leader-member exchange comparison

T2 - the role of procedural justice climate

AU - Tse, Herman H.M.

AU - Lam, Catherine K.

AU - Gu, Jun

AU - Lin, Xiao Song

PY - 2018/10

Y1 - 2018/10

N2 - Individuals are always sensitive to their relative standing in interpersonal comparison processes of leader-member exchanges (LMXs) in teams. Little research, however, has investigated whether coworkers with a higher LMX influence the emotional and behavioral reactions of individuals with a lower LMX in different dyads. Drawing on social comparison theory and the symbolic model of procedural justice (PJ) climate, we conducted 2 independent studies-an experimental study focusing on the self-perceived upward LMX comparison (i.e., an individual perceives that a coworker's LMX is higher than the LMX that he or she has with the supervisor; N = 203; Study 1: American working adults) and a field survey study focusing on the other-perceived downward LMX comparison (i.e., a coworker perceives that his or her own LMX is higher than the LMX that the individual has with the supervisor; N = 177; Study 2: Chinese software engineers). Results from these studies consistently revealed that a coworker's higher LMX elicits an individual's hostile emotions when the PJ climate is low but that this relationship is buffered when the PJ climate is high. Results of both studies also showed that the coworker's higher LMX arouses the individual to direct harmful behavior toward that coworker (via the individual's feelings of hostility) when the PJ climate is low but not when it is high.

AB - Individuals are always sensitive to their relative standing in interpersonal comparison processes of leader-member exchanges (LMXs) in teams. Little research, however, has investigated whether coworkers with a higher LMX influence the emotional and behavioral reactions of individuals with a lower LMX in different dyads. Drawing on social comparison theory and the symbolic model of procedural justice (PJ) climate, we conducted 2 independent studies-an experimental study focusing on the self-perceived upward LMX comparison (i.e., an individual perceives that a coworker's LMX is higher than the LMX that he or she has with the supervisor; N = 203; Study 1: American working adults) and a field survey study focusing on the other-perceived downward LMX comparison (i.e., a coworker perceives that his or her own LMX is higher than the LMX that the individual has with the supervisor; N = 177; Study 2: Chinese software engineers). Results from these studies consistently revealed that a coworker's higher LMX elicits an individual's hostile emotions when the PJ climate is low but that this relationship is buffered when the PJ climate is high. Results of both studies also showed that the coworker's higher LMX arouses the individual to direct harmful behavior toward that coworker (via the individual's feelings of hostility) when the PJ climate is low but not when it is high.

KW - Coworker dyads

KW - Interpersonal hostility and harming

KW - Leader-member exchange (LMX) comparison

KW - Procedural justice climate

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85041660692&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/job.2268

DO - 10.1002/job.2268

M3 - Article

VL - 39

SP - 922

EP - 940

JO - Journal of Organizational Behavior

JF - Journal of Organizational Behavior

SN - 0894-3796

IS - 8

ER -