Evaluation of the QUIC-URB wind solver and QESRadiant radiation-transfer model using a dense array of urban meteorological observations

Pascale Girard, Daniel F. Nadeau, Eric R. Pardyjak, Matthew Overby, Peter Willemsen, Rob Stoll, Brian N. Bailey, Marc B. Parlange

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

This study assesses the performance of QUIC-URB, a fast-response urban flow model, and QESRadiant, a ray tracing radiation transfer model. Both models are components of the QUIC EnvSim 3D urban micro-scale model, which aims to simulate meteorological variables at high spatiotemporal resolution (~1min, ~1m) in urban settings. The evaluation was performed over a 5.85ha sector of a university campus, in which complex 3D building geometry, vegetation, and various surface materials were modelled. First, wind speeds computed with QUIC-URB were compared to 30-min measurements over 10days at 19 locations. Although results showed a significant underestimation for locations in the wake of buildings, considering model assumptions, its inexpensive computational cost, and measurement uncertainty, the agreement between computed and measured wind speeds is good (r2 =0.53, mean absolute error=0.68ms-1). Second, incoming radiation computed with QESRadiant was compared to 2-min measurements over seven clear sky days at 17 locations. Overall, the agreement between computed and measured incoming solar radiation was excellent (r2 =0.95). For both models, simulations were run successfully on a standard laptop machine with highly reasonable computational cost, on the order of minutes.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)657-674
Number of pages18
JournalUrban Climate
Volume24
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2018
Externally publishedYes

Keywords

  • Building resolving
  • Model validation
  • Ray-tracing
  • Urban flow
  • Urban vegetation

Cite this

Girard, Pascale ; Nadeau, Daniel F. ; Pardyjak, Eric R. ; Overby, Matthew ; Willemsen, Peter ; Stoll, Rob ; Bailey, Brian N. ; Parlange, Marc B. / Evaluation of the QUIC-URB wind solver and QESRadiant radiation-transfer model using a dense array of urban meteorological observations. In: Urban Climate. 2018 ; Vol. 24. pp. 657-674.
@article{8dbe740a1d214895a1eae1ca54e49c5a,
title = "Evaluation of the QUIC-URB wind solver and QESRadiant radiation-transfer model using a dense array of urban meteorological observations",
abstract = "This study assesses the performance of QUIC-URB, a fast-response urban flow model, and QESRadiant, a ray tracing radiation transfer model. Both models are components of the QUIC EnvSim 3D urban micro-scale model, which aims to simulate meteorological variables at high spatiotemporal resolution (~1min, ~1m) in urban settings. The evaluation was performed over a 5.85ha sector of a university campus, in which complex 3D building geometry, vegetation, and various surface materials were modelled. First, wind speeds computed with QUIC-URB were compared to 30-min measurements over 10days at 19 locations. Although results showed a significant underestimation for locations in the wake of buildings, considering model assumptions, its inexpensive computational cost, and measurement uncertainty, the agreement between computed and measured wind speeds is good (r2 =0.53, mean absolute error=0.68ms-1). Second, incoming radiation computed with QESRadiant was compared to 2-min measurements over seven clear sky days at 17 locations. Overall, the agreement between computed and measured incoming solar radiation was excellent (r2 =0.95). For both models, simulations were run successfully on a standard laptop machine with highly reasonable computational cost, on the order of minutes.",
keywords = "Building resolving, Model validation, Ray-tracing, Urban flow, Urban vegetation",
author = "Pascale Girard and Nadeau, {Daniel F.} and Pardyjak, {Eric R.} and Matthew Overby and Peter Willemsen and Rob Stoll and Bailey, {Brian N.} and Parlange, {Marc B.}",
year = "2018",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1016/j.uclim.2017.08.006",
language = "English",
volume = "24",
pages = "657--674",
journal = "Urban Climate",
issn = "2212-0955",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

Evaluation of the QUIC-URB wind solver and QESRadiant radiation-transfer model using a dense array of urban meteorological observations. / Girard, Pascale; Nadeau, Daniel F.; Pardyjak, Eric R.; Overby, Matthew; Willemsen, Peter; Stoll, Rob; Bailey, Brian N.; Parlange, Marc B.

In: Urban Climate, Vol. 24, 06.2018, p. 657-674.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Evaluation of the QUIC-URB wind solver and QESRadiant radiation-transfer model using a dense array of urban meteorological observations

AU - Girard, Pascale

AU - Nadeau, Daniel F.

AU - Pardyjak, Eric R.

AU - Overby, Matthew

AU - Willemsen, Peter

AU - Stoll, Rob

AU - Bailey, Brian N.

AU - Parlange, Marc B.

PY - 2018/6

Y1 - 2018/6

N2 - This study assesses the performance of QUIC-URB, a fast-response urban flow model, and QESRadiant, a ray tracing radiation transfer model. Both models are components of the QUIC EnvSim 3D urban micro-scale model, which aims to simulate meteorological variables at high spatiotemporal resolution (~1min, ~1m) in urban settings. The evaluation was performed over a 5.85ha sector of a university campus, in which complex 3D building geometry, vegetation, and various surface materials were modelled. First, wind speeds computed with QUIC-URB were compared to 30-min measurements over 10days at 19 locations. Although results showed a significant underestimation for locations in the wake of buildings, considering model assumptions, its inexpensive computational cost, and measurement uncertainty, the agreement between computed and measured wind speeds is good (r2 =0.53, mean absolute error=0.68ms-1). Second, incoming radiation computed with QESRadiant was compared to 2-min measurements over seven clear sky days at 17 locations. Overall, the agreement between computed and measured incoming solar radiation was excellent (r2 =0.95). For both models, simulations were run successfully on a standard laptop machine with highly reasonable computational cost, on the order of minutes.

AB - This study assesses the performance of QUIC-URB, a fast-response urban flow model, and QESRadiant, a ray tracing radiation transfer model. Both models are components of the QUIC EnvSim 3D urban micro-scale model, which aims to simulate meteorological variables at high spatiotemporal resolution (~1min, ~1m) in urban settings. The evaluation was performed over a 5.85ha sector of a university campus, in which complex 3D building geometry, vegetation, and various surface materials were modelled. First, wind speeds computed with QUIC-URB were compared to 30-min measurements over 10days at 19 locations. Although results showed a significant underestimation for locations in the wake of buildings, considering model assumptions, its inexpensive computational cost, and measurement uncertainty, the agreement between computed and measured wind speeds is good (r2 =0.53, mean absolute error=0.68ms-1). Second, incoming radiation computed with QESRadiant was compared to 2-min measurements over seven clear sky days at 17 locations. Overall, the agreement between computed and measured incoming solar radiation was excellent (r2 =0.95). For both models, simulations were run successfully on a standard laptop machine with highly reasonable computational cost, on the order of minutes.

KW - Building resolving

KW - Model validation

KW - Ray-tracing

KW - Urban flow

KW - Urban vegetation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85027510148&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.uclim.2017.08.006

DO - 10.1016/j.uclim.2017.08.006

M3 - Article

VL - 24

SP - 657

EP - 674

JO - Urban Climate

JF - Urban Climate

SN - 2212-0955

ER -