Evaluation of the Medical Management and Preventability of Death in 137 Road Traffic Fatalities in Victoria, Australia

An Overview

F. T. McDermott, S. M. Cordner, A. B. Tremayne, Chris Atkin, Afif Hadj, Peter Ryan, Bruce Waxman, Graeme Brazenor, Jeffrey Rosenfel, Michael Murphy, Peter Dorhmann, John Laidlaw, Max Esser, Gary Grossbard, Linas Dziukas, Richard Harrod, Johannes Wenzel, Bill Shearer, Tony Weaver, Graeme Duke & 7 others Jamie Cooper, Peter Morley, David Sell, Greg Cooper, Gordon Trinca, Stephen Cordner, Frank McDermott

Research output: Contribution to journalReview ArticleResearchpeer-review

69 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objectives: In 1992 a multidisciplinary committee was established to identify problems in the management of road fatalities in Victoria, Australia, to assess their contribution to death, and to identify preventable deaths (preventable: survival probability more than 75%; potentially preventable: 25 to 75%). Methods: For 1992 and 1993 all 137 fatality cases surviving until arrival of ambulance services were evaluated by analysis and discussion of their complete prehospital, hospital, and autopsy records. Results: 1,012 problems were identified in 509 admissions to the various areas of care. Six hundred eighty-five (68%) were management errors and 217 (21%) were system inadequacies. Technique errors (45 (4%)), diagnosis delays (25 (2%)), and diagnosis errors (40 (4%)) were less frequent. The emergency department (ED) accounted for 537 (53%) problems, followed by prehospital (200 (20%)) and intensive care unit (118 (12%)). Four hundred seventy (46%) problems were assessed as contributing to death. Two hundred twenty-eight (49%) occurred in the ED, 90 (19%) were prehospital problems, and 63 (13%) occurred in the intensive care unit. Management errors comprised 326 (69%) problems contributing to death, and system inadequacies 88 (19%). Resuscitation problems accounted for 82 (49%) of the 167 ED management errors contributing to death. Eighty-five (62%) deaths were assessed as nonpreventable, 7 (5%) as preventable, and 45 (33%) as potentially preventable. Conclusion: Organizational and educational counter measures are required to reduce the high frequency of problems in emergency services and clinical management.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)520-533
Number of pages14
JournalThe Journal of Trauma: Injury, Infection, and Critical Care
Volume40
Issue number4
Publication statusPublished - 1 Apr 1996

Keywords

  • Emergency medical services
  • Evaluation studies
  • Hospital mortality
  • Mortality
  • Traffic accidents
  • Trauma severity indices
  • Triage
  • Wounds and injuries

Cite this

McDermott, F. T. ; Cordner, S. M. ; Tremayne, A. B. ; Atkin, Chris ; Hadj, Afif ; Ryan, Peter ; Waxman, Bruce ; Brazenor, Graeme ; Rosenfel, Jeffrey ; Murphy, Michael ; Dorhmann, Peter ; Laidlaw, John ; Esser, Max ; Grossbard, Gary ; Dziukas, Linas ; Harrod, Richard ; Wenzel, Johannes ; Shearer, Bill ; Weaver, Tony ; Duke, Graeme ; Cooper, Jamie ; Morley, Peter ; Sell, David ; Cooper, Greg ; Trinca, Gordon ; Cordner, Stephen ; McDermott, Frank. / Evaluation of the Medical Management and Preventability of Death in 137 Road Traffic Fatalities in Victoria, Australia : An Overview. In: The Journal of Trauma: Injury, Infection, and Critical Care. 1996 ; Vol. 40, No. 4. pp. 520-533.
@article{e7af43fa7e7044a9a6d527c839913990,
title = "Evaluation of the Medical Management and Preventability of Death in 137 Road Traffic Fatalities in Victoria, Australia: An Overview",
abstract = "Objectives: In 1992 a multidisciplinary committee was established to identify problems in the management of road fatalities in Victoria, Australia, to assess their contribution to death, and to identify preventable deaths (preventable: survival probability more than 75{\%}; potentially preventable: 25 to 75{\%}). Methods: For 1992 and 1993 all 137 fatality cases surviving until arrival of ambulance services were evaluated by analysis and discussion of their complete prehospital, hospital, and autopsy records. Results: 1,012 problems were identified in 509 admissions to the various areas of care. Six hundred eighty-five (68{\%}) were management errors and 217 (21{\%}) were system inadequacies. Technique errors (45 (4{\%})), diagnosis delays (25 (2{\%})), and diagnosis errors (40 (4{\%})) were less frequent. The emergency department (ED) accounted for 537 (53{\%}) problems, followed by prehospital (200 (20{\%})) and intensive care unit (118 (12{\%})). Four hundred seventy (46{\%}) problems were assessed as contributing to death. Two hundred twenty-eight (49{\%}) occurred in the ED, 90 (19{\%}) were prehospital problems, and 63 (13{\%}) occurred in the intensive care unit. Management errors comprised 326 (69{\%}) problems contributing to death, and system inadequacies 88 (19{\%}). Resuscitation problems accounted for 82 (49{\%}) of the 167 ED management errors contributing to death. Eighty-five (62{\%}) deaths were assessed as nonpreventable, 7 (5{\%}) as preventable, and 45 (33{\%}) as potentially preventable. Conclusion: Organizational and educational counter measures are required to reduce the high frequency of problems in emergency services and clinical management.",
keywords = "Emergency medical services, Evaluation studies, Hospital mortality, Mortality, Traffic accidents, Trauma severity indices, Triage, Wounds and injuries",
author = "McDermott, {F. T.} and Cordner, {S. M.} and Tremayne, {A. B.} and Chris Atkin and Afif Hadj and Peter Ryan and Bruce Waxman and Graeme Brazenor and Jeffrey Rosenfel and Michael Murphy and Peter Dorhmann and John Laidlaw and Max Esser and Gary Grossbard and Linas Dziukas and Richard Harrod and Johannes Wenzel and Bill Shearer and Tony Weaver and Graeme Duke and Jamie Cooper and Peter Morley and David Sell and Greg Cooper and Gordon Trinca and Stephen Cordner and Frank McDermott",
year = "1996",
month = "4",
day = "1",
language = "English",
volume = "40",
pages = "520--533",
journal = "The Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery",
issn = "2163-0755",
publisher = "Lippincott Williams & Wilkins",
number = "4",

}

McDermott, FT, Cordner, SM, Tremayne, AB, Atkin, C, Hadj, A, Ryan, P, Waxman, B, Brazenor, G, Rosenfel, J, Murphy, M, Dorhmann, P, Laidlaw, J, Esser, M, Grossbard, G, Dziukas, L, Harrod, R, Wenzel, J, Shearer, B, Weaver, T, Duke, G, Cooper, J, Morley, P, Sell, D, Cooper, G, Trinca, G, Cordner, S & McDermott, F 1996, 'Evaluation of the Medical Management and Preventability of Death in 137 Road Traffic Fatalities in Victoria, Australia: An Overview', The Journal of Trauma: Injury, Infection, and Critical Care, vol. 40, no. 4, pp. 520-533.

Evaluation of the Medical Management and Preventability of Death in 137 Road Traffic Fatalities in Victoria, Australia : An Overview. / McDermott, F. T.; Cordner, S. M.; Tremayne, A. B.; Atkin, Chris; Hadj, Afif; Ryan, Peter; Waxman, Bruce; Brazenor, Graeme; Rosenfel, Jeffrey; Murphy, Michael; Dorhmann, Peter; Laidlaw, John; Esser, Max; Grossbard, Gary; Dziukas, Linas; Harrod, Richard; Wenzel, Johannes; Shearer, Bill; Weaver, Tony; Duke, Graeme; Cooper, Jamie; Morley, Peter; Sell, David; Cooper, Greg; Trinca, Gordon; Cordner, Stephen; McDermott, Frank.

In: The Journal of Trauma: Injury, Infection, and Critical Care, Vol. 40, No. 4, 01.04.1996, p. 520-533.

Research output: Contribution to journalReview ArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Evaluation of the Medical Management and Preventability of Death in 137 Road Traffic Fatalities in Victoria, Australia

T2 - An Overview

AU - McDermott, F. T.

AU - Cordner, S. M.

AU - Tremayne, A. B.

AU - Atkin, Chris

AU - Hadj, Afif

AU - Ryan, Peter

AU - Waxman, Bruce

AU - Brazenor, Graeme

AU - Rosenfel, Jeffrey

AU - Murphy, Michael

AU - Dorhmann, Peter

AU - Laidlaw, John

AU - Esser, Max

AU - Grossbard, Gary

AU - Dziukas, Linas

AU - Harrod, Richard

AU - Wenzel, Johannes

AU - Shearer, Bill

AU - Weaver, Tony

AU - Duke, Graeme

AU - Cooper, Jamie

AU - Morley, Peter

AU - Sell, David

AU - Cooper, Greg

AU - Trinca, Gordon

AU - Cordner, Stephen

AU - McDermott, Frank

PY - 1996/4/1

Y1 - 1996/4/1

N2 - Objectives: In 1992 a multidisciplinary committee was established to identify problems in the management of road fatalities in Victoria, Australia, to assess their contribution to death, and to identify preventable deaths (preventable: survival probability more than 75%; potentially preventable: 25 to 75%). Methods: For 1992 and 1993 all 137 fatality cases surviving until arrival of ambulance services were evaluated by analysis and discussion of their complete prehospital, hospital, and autopsy records. Results: 1,012 problems were identified in 509 admissions to the various areas of care. Six hundred eighty-five (68%) were management errors and 217 (21%) were system inadequacies. Technique errors (45 (4%)), diagnosis delays (25 (2%)), and diagnosis errors (40 (4%)) were less frequent. The emergency department (ED) accounted for 537 (53%) problems, followed by prehospital (200 (20%)) and intensive care unit (118 (12%)). Four hundred seventy (46%) problems were assessed as contributing to death. Two hundred twenty-eight (49%) occurred in the ED, 90 (19%) were prehospital problems, and 63 (13%) occurred in the intensive care unit. Management errors comprised 326 (69%) problems contributing to death, and system inadequacies 88 (19%). Resuscitation problems accounted for 82 (49%) of the 167 ED management errors contributing to death. Eighty-five (62%) deaths were assessed as nonpreventable, 7 (5%) as preventable, and 45 (33%) as potentially preventable. Conclusion: Organizational and educational counter measures are required to reduce the high frequency of problems in emergency services and clinical management.

AB - Objectives: In 1992 a multidisciplinary committee was established to identify problems in the management of road fatalities in Victoria, Australia, to assess their contribution to death, and to identify preventable deaths (preventable: survival probability more than 75%; potentially preventable: 25 to 75%). Methods: For 1992 and 1993 all 137 fatality cases surviving until arrival of ambulance services were evaluated by analysis and discussion of their complete prehospital, hospital, and autopsy records. Results: 1,012 problems were identified in 509 admissions to the various areas of care. Six hundred eighty-five (68%) were management errors and 217 (21%) were system inadequacies. Technique errors (45 (4%)), diagnosis delays (25 (2%)), and diagnosis errors (40 (4%)) were less frequent. The emergency department (ED) accounted for 537 (53%) problems, followed by prehospital (200 (20%)) and intensive care unit (118 (12%)). Four hundred seventy (46%) problems were assessed as contributing to death. Two hundred twenty-eight (49%) occurred in the ED, 90 (19%) were prehospital problems, and 63 (13%) occurred in the intensive care unit. Management errors comprised 326 (69%) problems contributing to death, and system inadequacies 88 (19%). Resuscitation problems accounted for 82 (49%) of the 167 ED management errors contributing to death. Eighty-five (62%) deaths were assessed as nonpreventable, 7 (5%) as preventable, and 45 (33%) as potentially preventable. Conclusion: Organizational and educational counter measures are required to reduce the high frequency of problems in emergency services and clinical management.

KW - Emergency medical services

KW - Evaluation studies

KW - Hospital mortality

KW - Mortality

KW - Traffic accidents

KW - Trauma severity indices

KW - Triage

KW - Wounds and injuries

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0029932505&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Review Article

VL - 40

SP - 520

EP - 533

JO - The Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery

JF - The Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery

SN - 2163-0755

IS - 4

ER -