Emotion and consumption: toward a new understanding of cultural collisions between Hong Kong and PRC luxury consumers

Annamma Joy, Russell W. Belk, Jeff Jianfeng Wang, John F. Sherry

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Incorporating Illouz’s theory of emotions, this study examines how specific emotions drive consumption, as embodied by escalating conflicts between Hong Kong and the PRC luxury consumers. When affluent Mainlanders pursue status signifiers via consumption of relatively affordable luxury goods in Hong Kong, local residents’ disdain triggers a nexus of emotions: envy, resentment, and status anxiety, linked to fears of being occupied by and assimilated into Chinese culture. Deploying cultural capital and status competition rooted in imagination and refinement, Hong Kongese contrast their knowledge-based use of luxury brands with the avid consumption of PRC visitors, fueled by often extreme wealth. For Hong Kongese, such one-upmanship degenerates into self-doubt and self-failure in their image management attempts, precipitating intense hostility toward PRC consumers. Emotions engender colliding notions of self, status, and cultural and political identity between these disparate yet intertwined cultures.

Original languageEnglish
Number of pages20
JournalJournal of Consumer Culture
DOIs
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 1 Jan 2018

Keywords

  • adaptation strategies
  • cultural capital
  • emotions
  • friction and conflict
  • Luxury consumption
  • status competition

Cite this

@article{4ac8f052edc74f80aa45aaf2c3eccde6,
title = "Emotion and consumption: toward a new understanding of cultural collisions between Hong Kong and PRC luxury consumers",
abstract = "Incorporating Illouz’s theory of emotions, this study examines how specific emotions drive consumption, as embodied by escalating conflicts between Hong Kong and the PRC luxury consumers. When affluent Mainlanders pursue status signifiers via consumption of relatively affordable luxury goods in Hong Kong, local residents’ disdain triggers a nexus of emotions: envy, resentment, and status anxiety, linked to fears of being occupied by and assimilated into Chinese culture. Deploying cultural capital and status competition rooted in imagination and refinement, Hong Kongese contrast their knowledge-based use of luxury brands with the avid consumption of PRC visitors, fueled by often extreme wealth. For Hong Kongese, such one-upmanship degenerates into self-doubt and self-failure in their image management attempts, precipitating intense hostility toward PRC consumers. Emotions engender colliding notions of self, status, and cultural and political identity between these disparate yet intertwined cultures.",
keywords = "adaptation strategies, cultural capital, emotions, friction and conflict, Luxury consumption, status competition",
author = "Annamma Joy and Belk, {Russell W.} and Wang, {Jeff Jianfeng} and Sherry, {John F.}",
year = "2018",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1177/1469540518764247",
language = "English",
journal = "Journal of Consumer Culture",
issn = "1469-5405",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd",

}

Emotion and consumption : toward a new understanding of cultural collisions between Hong Kong and PRC luxury consumers. / Joy, Annamma; Belk, Russell W.; Wang, Jeff Jianfeng; Sherry, John F.

In: Journal of Consumer Culture, 01.01.2018.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Emotion and consumption

T2 - toward a new understanding of cultural collisions between Hong Kong and PRC luxury consumers

AU - Joy, Annamma

AU - Belk, Russell W.

AU - Wang, Jeff Jianfeng

AU - Sherry, John F.

PY - 2018/1/1

Y1 - 2018/1/1

N2 - Incorporating Illouz’s theory of emotions, this study examines how specific emotions drive consumption, as embodied by escalating conflicts between Hong Kong and the PRC luxury consumers. When affluent Mainlanders pursue status signifiers via consumption of relatively affordable luxury goods in Hong Kong, local residents’ disdain triggers a nexus of emotions: envy, resentment, and status anxiety, linked to fears of being occupied by and assimilated into Chinese culture. Deploying cultural capital and status competition rooted in imagination and refinement, Hong Kongese contrast their knowledge-based use of luxury brands with the avid consumption of PRC visitors, fueled by often extreme wealth. For Hong Kongese, such one-upmanship degenerates into self-doubt and self-failure in their image management attempts, precipitating intense hostility toward PRC consumers. Emotions engender colliding notions of self, status, and cultural and political identity between these disparate yet intertwined cultures.

AB - Incorporating Illouz’s theory of emotions, this study examines how specific emotions drive consumption, as embodied by escalating conflicts between Hong Kong and the PRC luxury consumers. When affluent Mainlanders pursue status signifiers via consumption of relatively affordable luxury goods in Hong Kong, local residents’ disdain triggers a nexus of emotions: envy, resentment, and status anxiety, linked to fears of being occupied by and assimilated into Chinese culture. Deploying cultural capital and status competition rooted in imagination and refinement, Hong Kongese contrast their knowledge-based use of luxury brands with the avid consumption of PRC visitors, fueled by often extreme wealth. For Hong Kongese, such one-upmanship degenerates into self-doubt and self-failure in their image management attempts, precipitating intense hostility toward PRC consumers. Emotions engender colliding notions of self, status, and cultural and political identity between these disparate yet intertwined cultures.

KW - adaptation strategies

KW - cultural capital

KW - emotions

KW - friction and conflict

KW - Luxury consumption

KW - status competition

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85044474828&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/1469540518764247

DO - 10.1177/1469540518764247

M3 - Article

JO - Journal of Consumer Culture

JF - Journal of Consumer Culture

SN - 1469-5405

ER -