Educational games as a motivational tool: considerations on their potential and limitations

Marcello Passarelli, Francesca Maria Dagnino, Jeffrey Earp, Flavio Manganello, Donatella Persico, Francesca Pozzi, Chris Bailey, Carlo Perrotta, Thomas Buijtenweg, Mata Haggis

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference PaperResearchpeer-review

Abstract

There is considerable interest in leveraging video games to support students’ motivation. This involves employment of educational (serious) and entertainment games. However, while evidence indicates that games can enhance learning outcomes, doubts persist about whether they retain their enjoyable character in formal learning contexts. This study was carried out within the H2020 Gaming Horizons project, which involved a review of academic literature on the role of games in society, as well as 73 semi-structured interviews with relevant stakeholders, including players and educators, investigating their positions on game-related issues. The interviews suggested that players tend to view game-based learning – and specifically serious games at school – with scepticism. This is partly attributable to the perception that serious games have lower production values than entertainment games, and that gaming, as a voluntary, self-driven activity, clashes with the structured nature of school. Some educators reported individual and gender differences in the motivating power of games. However, the use of entertainment games to foster learning outcomes was seen favourably. Two focus groups devoted to the issue highlighted the need for carefully tailoring the gaming experience to both context and student, and the importance of developing a sustainable business model for enhancing serious games quality.

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationCSEDU 2019
Subtitle of host publicationProceedings of the 11th International Conference on Computer Supported Education
EditorsH. Lane, Susan Zvacek, James Uhomoibhi
Place of PublicationPortugal
PublisherScitepress
Pages330-337
Number of pages8
Volume1
Edition1st
ISBN (Electronic)9789897583674
Publication statusPublished - 2019
EventInternational Conference on Computer Supported Education 2019 - Heraklion, Crete, Greece
Duration: 2 May 20194 May 2019
Conference number: 11th

Conference

ConferenceInternational Conference on Computer Supported Education 2019
Abbreviated titleCSEDU 2019
CountryGreece
CityHeraklion, Crete
Period2/05/194/05/19

Keywords

  • Game-based Learning
  • Gamification
  • Motivation
  • Serious Games

Cite this

Passarelli, M., Dagnino, F. M., Earp, J., Manganello, F., Persico, D., Pozzi, F., ... Haggis, M. (2019). Educational games as a motivational tool: considerations on their potential and limitations. In H. Lane, S. Zvacek, & J. Uhomoibhi (Eds.), CSEDU 2019: Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on Computer Supported Education (1st ed., Vol. 1, pp. 330-337). Portugal: Scitepress.
Passarelli, Marcello ; Dagnino, Francesca Maria ; Earp, Jeffrey ; Manganello, Flavio ; Persico, Donatella ; Pozzi, Francesca ; Bailey, Chris ; Perrotta, Carlo ; Buijtenweg, Thomas ; Haggis, Mata. / Educational games as a motivational tool : considerations on their potential and limitations. CSEDU 2019: Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on Computer Supported Education. editor / H. Lane ; Susan Zvacek ; James Uhomoibhi. Vol. 1 1st. ed. Portugal : Scitepress, 2019. pp. 330-337
@inproceedings{bfecd8abf4d3476c9af3345e61ece044,
title = "Educational games as a motivational tool: considerations on their potential and limitations",
abstract = "There is considerable interest in leveraging video games to support students’ motivation. This involves employment of educational (serious) and entertainment games. However, while evidence indicates that games can enhance learning outcomes, doubts persist about whether they retain their enjoyable character in formal learning contexts. This study was carried out within the H2020 Gaming Horizons project, which involved a review of academic literature on the role of games in society, as well as 73 semi-structured interviews with relevant stakeholders, including players and educators, investigating their positions on game-related issues. The interviews suggested that players tend to view game-based learning – and specifically serious games at school – with scepticism. This is partly attributable to the perception that serious games have lower production values than entertainment games, and that gaming, as a voluntary, self-driven activity, clashes with the structured nature of school. Some educators reported individual and gender differences in the motivating power of games. However, the use of entertainment games to foster learning outcomes was seen favourably. Two focus groups devoted to the issue highlighted the need for carefully tailoring the gaming experience to both context and student, and the importance of developing a sustainable business model for enhancing serious games quality.",
keywords = "Game-based Learning, Gamification, Motivation, Serious Games",
author = "Marcello Passarelli and Dagnino, {Francesca Maria} and Jeffrey Earp and Flavio Manganello and Donatella Persico and Francesca Pozzi and Chris Bailey and Carlo Perrotta and Thomas Buijtenweg and Mata Haggis",
year = "2019",
language = "English",
volume = "1",
pages = "330--337",
editor = "H. Lane and Susan Zvacek and James Uhomoibhi",
booktitle = "CSEDU 2019",
publisher = "Scitepress",
edition = "1st",

}

Passarelli, M, Dagnino, FM, Earp, J, Manganello, F, Persico, D, Pozzi, F, Bailey, C, Perrotta, C, Buijtenweg, T & Haggis, M 2019, Educational games as a motivational tool: considerations on their potential and limitations. in H Lane, S Zvacek & J Uhomoibhi (eds), CSEDU 2019: Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on Computer Supported Education. 1st edn, vol. 1, Scitepress, Portugal, pp. 330-337, International Conference on Computer Supported Education 2019, Heraklion, Crete, Greece, 2/05/19.

Educational games as a motivational tool : considerations on their potential and limitations. / Passarelli, Marcello; Dagnino, Francesca Maria; Earp, Jeffrey; Manganello, Flavio; Persico, Donatella; Pozzi, Francesca; Bailey, Chris; Perrotta, Carlo; Buijtenweg, Thomas; Haggis, Mata.

CSEDU 2019: Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on Computer Supported Education. ed. / H. Lane; Susan Zvacek; James Uhomoibhi. Vol. 1 1st. ed. Portugal : Scitepress, 2019. p. 330-337.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference PaperResearchpeer-review

TY - GEN

T1 - Educational games as a motivational tool

T2 - considerations on their potential and limitations

AU - Passarelli, Marcello

AU - Dagnino, Francesca Maria

AU - Earp, Jeffrey

AU - Manganello, Flavio

AU - Persico, Donatella

AU - Pozzi, Francesca

AU - Bailey, Chris

AU - Perrotta, Carlo

AU - Buijtenweg, Thomas

AU - Haggis, Mata

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - There is considerable interest in leveraging video games to support students’ motivation. This involves employment of educational (serious) and entertainment games. However, while evidence indicates that games can enhance learning outcomes, doubts persist about whether they retain their enjoyable character in formal learning contexts. This study was carried out within the H2020 Gaming Horizons project, which involved a review of academic literature on the role of games in society, as well as 73 semi-structured interviews with relevant stakeholders, including players and educators, investigating their positions on game-related issues. The interviews suggested that players tend to view game-based learning – and specifically serious games at school – with scepticism. This is partly attributable to the perception that serious games have lower production values than entertainment games, and that gaming, as a voluntary, self-driven activity, clashes with the structured nature of school. Some educators reported individual and gender differences in the motivating power of games. However, the use of entertainment games to foster learning outcomes was seen favourably. Two focus groups devoted to the issue highlighted the need for carefully tailoring the gaming experience to both context and student, and the importance of developing a sustainable business model for enhancing serious games quality.

AB - There is considerable interest in leveraging video games to support students’ motivation. This involves employment of educational (serious) and entertainment games. However, while evidence indicates that games can enhance learning outcomes, doubts persist about whether they retain their enjoyable character in formal learning contexts. This study was carried out within the H2020 Gaming Horizons project, which involved a review of academic literature on the role of games in society, as well as 73 semi-structured interviews with relevant stakeholders, including players and educators, investigating their positions on game-related issues. The interviews suggested that players tend to view game-based learning – and specifically serious games at school – with scepticism. This is partly attributable to the perception that serious games have lower production values than entertainment games, and that gaming, as a voluntary, self-driven activity, clashes with the structured nature of school. Some educators reported individual and gender differences in the motivating power of games. However, the use of entertainment games to foster learning outcomes was seen favourably. Two focus groups devoted to the issue highlighted the need for carefully tailoring the gaming experience to both context and student, and the importance of developing a sustainable business model for enhancing serious games quality.

KW - Game-based Learning

KW - Gamification

KW - Motivation

KW - Serious Games

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85063696994&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Conference Paper

VL - 1

SP - 330

EP - 337

BT - CSEDU 2019

A2 - Lane, H.

A2 - Zvacek, Susan

A2 - Uhomoibhi, James

PB - Scitepress

CY - Portugal

ER -

Passarelli M, Dagnino FM, Earp J, Manganello F, Persico D, Pozzi F et al. Educational games as a motivational tool: considerations on their potential and limitations. In Lane H, Zvacek S, Uhomoibhi J, editors, CSEDU 2019: Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on Computer Supported Education. 1st ed. Vol. 1. Portugal: Scitepress. 2019. p. 330-337