Countering pernicious images

memetic visual propaganda and the 2018 elections

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Russian disinformation attacks through social media increasingly involve genuine photos paired with inaccurate captions to create false news. The relative ease and devastating impact of this meme-based (memetic) method has led domestic actors to adopt these same informational warfare tactics. This is apparent in an examination of the conservative effort to demonize the migrant caravan in the month before the 2018 midterm elections. Posters used miscaptioned images to push xenophobic tropes that the caravan was violent, rapacious, diseased, unpatriotic, and supported by outside funding groups including wealthy Jews. This article is the first to systematically document these propagandist threads and presents a legal countermeasure based on existing intellectual property and First Amendment doctrines.
Tracing the development of memetic misattribution reveals a powerful avenue for defense. Falsely captioned photographs in these memes typically originate from previously published news articles and are reused over several years. As such, a basic reverse image search can debunk the majority of these images; a photo cannot simultaneously capture current events and predate those events by several years. Social media firms should incorporate reverse image searches and resultant copyright information directly on their sites. This effort is imperative, as these firms have been slow to respond to this informational threat to our democracy. Moreover, an objective, measured approach is vital to avoid overregulating an important arena for speech. The novel transparency-based solution advanced in this article achieves this balance.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)79-160
Number of pages82
JournalSeton Hall Law Review
Volume50
Issue number1
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 2020

Keywords

  • Election law
  • propaganda
  • meme

Cite this

@article{b216a53f851c408d814df91f34d2976d,
title = "Countering pernicious images: memetic visual propaganda and the 2018 elections",
abstract = "Russian disinformation attacks through social media increasingly involve genuine photos paired with inaccurate captions to create false news. The relative ease and devastating impact of this meme-based (memetic) method has led domestic actors to adopt these same informational warfare tactics. This is apparent in an examination of the conservative effort to demonize the migrant caravan in the month before the 2018 midterm elections. Posters used miscaptioned images to push xenophobic tropes that the caravan was violent, rapacious, diseased, unpatriotic, and supported by outside funding groups including wealthy Jews. This article is the first to systematically document these propagandist threads and presents a legal countermeasure based on existing intellectual property and First Amendment doctrines.Tracing the development of memetic misattribution reveals a powerful avenue for defense. Falsely captioned photographs in these memes typically originate from previously published news articles and are reused over several years. As such, a basic reverse image search can debunk the majority of these images; a photo cannot simultaneously capture current events and predate those events by several years. Social media firms should incorporate reverse image searches and resultant copyright information directly on their sites. This effort is imperative, as these firms have been slow to respond to this informational threat to our democracy. Moreover, an objective, measured approach is vital to avoid overregulating an important arena for speech. The novel transparency-based solution advanced in this article achieves this balance.",
keywords = "Election law, propaganda, meme",
author = "Andrew Moshirnia",
year = "2020",
language = "English",
volume = "50",
pages = "79--160",
journal = "Seton Hall Law Review",
issn = "0586-5964",
number = "1",

}

Countering pernicious images : memetic visual propaganda and the 2018 elections. / Moshirnia, Andrew.

In: Seton Hall Law Review , Vol. 50, No. 1, 2020, p. 79-160.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Countering pernicious images

T2 - memetic visual propaganda and the 2018 elections

AU - Moshirnia, Andrew

PY - 2020

Y1 - 2020

N2 - Russian disinformation attacks through social media increasingly involve genuine photos paired with inaccurate captions to create false news. The relative ease and devastating impact of this meme-based (memetic) method has led domestic actors to adopt these same informational warfare tactics. This is apparent in an examination of the conservative effort to demonize the migrant caravan in the month before the 2018 midterm elections. Posters used miscaptioned images to push xenophobic tropes that the caravan was violent, rapacious, diseased, unpatriotic, and supported by outside funding groups including wealthy Jews. This article is the first to systematically document these propagandist threads and presents a legal countermeasure based on existing intellectual property and First Amendment doctrines.Tracing the development of memetic misattribution reveals a powerful avenue for defense. Falsely captioned photographs in these memes typically originate from previously published news articles and are reused over several years. As such, a basic reverse image search can debunk the majority of these images; a photo cannot simultaneously capture current events and predate those events by several years. Social media firms should incorporate reverse image searches and resultant copyright information directly on their sites. This effort is imperative, as these firms have been slow to respond to this informational threat to our democracy. Moreover, an objective, measured approach is vital to avoid overregulating an important arena for speech. The novel transparency-based solution advanced in this article achieves this balance.

AB - Russian disinformation attacks through social media increasingly involve genuine photos paired with inaccurate captions to create false news. The relative ease and devastating impact of this meme-based (memetic) method has led domestic actors to adopt these same informational warfare tactics. This is apparent in an examination of the conservative effort to demonize the migrant caravan in the month before the 2018 midterm elections. Posters used miscaptioned images to push xenophobic tropes that the caravan was violent, rapacious, diseased, unpatriotic, and supported by outside funding groups including wealthy Jews. This article is the first to systematically document these propagandist threads and presents a legal countermeasure based on existing intellectual property and First Amendment doctrines.Tracing the development of memetic misattribution reveals a powerful avenue for defense. Falsely captioned photographs in these memes typically originate from previously published news articles and are reused over several years. As such, a basic reverse image search can debunk the majority of these images; a photo cannot simultaneously capture current events and predate those events by several years. Social media firms should incorporate reverse image searches and resultant copyright information directly on their sites. This effort is imperative, as these firms have been slow to respond to this informational threat to our democracy. Moreover, an objective, measured approach is vital to avoid overregulating an important arena for speech. The novel transparency-based solution advanced in this article achieves this balance.

KW - Election law

KW - propaganda

KW - meme

M3 - Article

VL - 50

SP - 79

EP - 160

JO - Seton Hall Law Review

JF - Seton Hall Law Review

SN - 0586-5964

IS - 1

ER -