Corrosion-wear of β-Ti alloy TMZF (Ti-12Mo-6Zr-2Fe) in simulated body fluid

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

36 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Titanium alloys are popular metallic implant materials for use in total hip replacements. Although, α + β titanium alloys such as Ti-6Al-4V have been the most commonly used alloys, the high Young's modulus (∼110 GPa) leads to an undesirable stress shielding effect. An alternative is to use β titanium alloys that exhibit a significantly lower Young's modulus (∼70 GPa). Femoral stems made of a β titanium alloy known as TMZF (Ti-12Mo-6Zr-2Fe (wt.%)) have been used as part of modular hip replacements since the early 2000’s but these were recalled in 2011 by the US Food & Drug Administration (FDA) due to unacceptable levels of ‘wear debris’. The wear was caused by small relative movement of the stem and neck at the junction where they fit together in the modular hip replacement design. In this study, the corrosion and wear properties of the TMZF alloy were investigated in simulated body fluid to identify the reason for the wear debris generation. Ti64 was used as a control for comparison. It is shown that the interaction between the surfaces of Ti64 and TMZF with simulated body fluid is very similar, both from the point of view of the products formed and the kinetics of the reaction. The dry wear behaviour of TMZF is also close to that of Ti64 and consistent with expectations based on Archard's law for abrasive wear. However, wear of Ti64 and TMZF in simulated body fluid show contrasting behaviours. A type of time-dependent wear test is used to examine the synergy between corrosion and wear of TMZF and Ti64. It is shown that the wear of TMZF accelerated rapidly in SBF whereas that of Ti64 is reduced. The critical role of the strain hardening capacity of the two materials and its role in helping the surface resist abrasion by hydroxyapatite particles formed as a result of the reaction with the SBF is discussed and recommendations are made for modifications that could be made to the TMZF alloy to improve the corrosion-wear response. Statement of Significance TMZF is a low modulus β-Ti alloy that has been used as the femoral stem in the Stryker modular design total hip replacement. It went into service in the early 2000’s but was recalled by the FDA in 2011 due to unacceptable levels of wear debris released in the body which led to adverse physiological reactions. A large number of these implants remain in patients today. In this contribution, we investigate the corrosion (interaction of the alloy with simulated body fluid (SBF)), dry wear and then corrosion-wear in SBF to identify the origin of the unacceptable levels of wear that led to the FDA recall of this material. We use Ti-6Al-4V as a control and demonstrate that the reaction between Ti64 and TMZF with SBF is very similar in terms of both products formed and kinetics. We also show that the dry wear behaviour of TMZF is very similar to that of Ti64 and exactly as should be expected for the hardness of this material. However, the wear behaviours of TMZF and Ti64 are completed different in SBF and wear of TMZF is significantly accelerated in SBF. A type of time-dependent wear test is used to demonstrate the synergy between corrosion and wear and the key role of the strain hardening capacity (or lack thereof in the case of β-Ti) is discussed.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)429-439
Number of pages11
JournalActa Biomaterialia
Volume42
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 15 Sep 2016

Keywords

  • TMZF
  • Ti64
  • Corrosion-wear
  • Hip-implant
  • Simulated body fluid

Cite this

@article{ac979e81aad348eba4af0a4a25562c4b,
title = "Corrosion-wear of β-Ti alloy TMZF (Ti-12Mo-6Zr-2Fe) in simulated body fluid",
abstract = "Titanium alloys are popular metallic implant materials for use in total hip replacements. Although, α + β titanium alloys such as Ti-6Al-4V have been the most commonly used alloys, the high Young's modulus (∼110 GPa) leads to an undesirable stress shielding effect. An alternative is to use β titanium alloys that exhibit a significantly lower Young's modulus (∼70 GPa). Femoral stems made of a β titanium alloy known as TMZF (Ti-12Mo-6Zr-2Fe (wt.{\%})) have been used as part of modular hip replacements since the early 2000’s but these were recalled in 2011 by the US Food & Drug Administration (FDA) due to unacceptable levels of ‘wear debris’. The wear was caused by small relative movement of the stem and neck at the junction where they fit together in the modular hip replacement design. In this study, the corrosion and wear properties of the TMZF alloy were investigated in simulated body fluid to identify the reason for the wear debris generation. Ti64 was used as a control for comparison. It is shown that the interaction between the surfaces of Ti64 and TMZF with simulated body fluid is very similar, both from the point of view of the products formed and the kinetics of the reaction. The dry wear behaviour of TMZF is also close to that of Ti64 and consistent with expectations based on Archard's law for abrasive wear. However, wear of Ti64 and TMZF in simulated body fluid show contrasting behaviours. A type of time-dependent wear test is used to examine the synergy between corrosion and wear of TMZF and Ti64. It is shown that the wear of TMZF accelerated rapidly in SBF whereas that of Ti64 is reduced. The critical role of the strain hardening capacity of the two materials and its role in helping the surface resist abrasion by hydroxyapatite particles formed as a result of the reaction with the SBF is discussed and recommendations are made for modifications that could be made to the TMZF alloy to improve the corrosion-wear response. Statement of Significance TMZF is a low modulus β-Ti alloy that has been used as the femoral stem in the Stryker modular design total hip replacement. It went into service in the early 2000’s but was recalled by the FDA in 2011 due to unacceptable levels of wear debris released in the body which led to adverse physiological reactions. A large number of these implants remain in patients today. In this contribution, we investigate the corrosion (interaction of the alloy with simulated body fluid (SBF)), dry wear and then corrosion-wear in SBF to identify the origin of the unacceptable levels of wear that led to the FDA recall of this material. We use Ti-6Al-4V as a control and demonstrate that the reaction between Ti64 and TMZF with SBF is very similar in terms of both products formed and kinetics. We also show that the dry wear behaviour of TMZF is very similar to that of Ti64 and exactly as should be expected for the hardness of this material. However, the wear behaviours of TMZF and Ti64 are completed different in SBF and wear of TMZF is significantly accelerated in SBF. A type of time-dependent wear test is used to demonstrate the synergy between corrosion and wear and the key role of the strain hardening capacity (or lack thereof in the case of β-Ti) is discussed.",
keywords = "TMZF, Ti64, Corrosion-wear, Hip-implant, Simulated body fluid",
author = "Xueyuan Yang and Hutchinson, {Christopher R.}",
year = "2016",
month = "9",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1016/j.actbio.2016.07.008",
language = "English",
volume = "42",
pages = "429--439",
journal = "Acta Biomaterialia",
issn = "1742-7061",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

Corrosion-wear of β-Ti alloy TMZF (Ti-12Mo-6Zr-2Fe) in simulated body fluid. / Yang, Xueyuan; Hutchinson, Christopher R.

In: Acta Biomaterialia, Vol. 42, 15.09.2016, p. 429-439.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Corrosion-wear of β-Ti alloy TMZF (Ti-12Mo-6Zr-2Fe) in simulated body fluid

AU - Yang, Xueyuan

AU - Hutchinson, Christopher R.

PY - 2016/9/15

Y1 - 2016/9/15

N2 - Titanium alloys are popular metallic implant materials for use in total hip replacements. Although, α + β titanium alloys such as Ti-6Al-4V have been the most commonly used alloys, the high Young's modulus (∼110 GPa) leads to an undesirable stress shielding effect. An alternative is to use β titanium alloys that exhibit a significantly lower Young's modulus (∼70 GPa). Femoral stems made of a β titanium alloy known as TMZF (Ti-12Mo-6Zr-2Fe (wt.%)) have been used as part of modular hip replacements since the early 2000’s but these were recalled in 2011 by the US Food & Drug Administration (FDA) due to unacceptable levels of ‘wear debris’. The wear was caused by small relative movement of the stem and neck at the junction where they fit together in the modular hip replacement design. In this study, the corrosion and wear properties of the TMZF alloy were investigated in simulated body fluid to identify the reason for the wear debris generation. Ti64 was used as a control for comparison. It is shown that the interaction between the surfaces of Ti64 and TMZF with simulated body fluid is very similar, both from the point of view of the products formed and the kinetics of the reaction. The dry wear behaviour of TMZF is also close to that of Ti64 and consistent with expectations based on Archard's law for abrasive wear. However, wear of Ti64 and TMZF in simulated body fluid show contrasting behaviours. A type of time-dependent wear test is used to examine the synergy between corrosion and wear of TMZF and Ti64. It is shown that the wear of TMZF accelerated rapidly in SBF whereas that of Ti64 is reduced. The critical role of the strain hardening capacity of the two materials and its role in helping the surface resist abrasion by hydroxyapatite particles formed as a result of the reaction with the SBF is discussed and recommendations are made for modifications that could be made to the TMZF alloy to improve the corrosion-wear response. Statement of Significance TMZF is a low modulus β-Ti alloy that has been used as the femoral stem in the Stryker modular design total hip replacement. It went into service in the early 2000’s but was recalled by the FDA in 2011 due to unacceptable levels of wear debris released in the body which led to adverse physiological reactions. A large number of these implants remain in patients today. In this contribution, we investigate the corrosion (interaction of the alloy with simulated body fluid (SBF)), dry wear and then corrosion-wear in SBF to identify the origin of the unacceptable levels of wear that led to the FDA recall of this material. We use Ti-6Al-4V as a control and demonstrate that the reaction between Ti64 and TMZF with SBF is very similar in terms of both products formed and kinetics. We also show that the dry wear behaviour of TMZF is very similar to that of Ti64 and exactly as should be expected for the hardness of this material. However, the wear behaviours of TMZF and Ti64 are completed different in SBF and wear of TMZF is significantly accelerated in SBF. A type of time-dependent wear test is used to demonstrate the synergy between corrosion and wear and the key role of the strain hardening capacity (or lack thereof in the case of β-Ti) is discussed.

AB - Titanium alloys are popular metallic implant materials for use in total hip replacements. Although, α + β titanium alloys such as Ti-6Al-4V have been the most commonly used alloys, the high Young's modulus (∼110 GPa) leads to an undesirable stress shielding effect. An alternative is to use β titanium alloys that exhibit a significantly lower Young's modulus (∼70 GPa). Femoral stems made of a β titanium alloy known as TMZF (Ti-12Mo-6Zr-2Fe (wt.%)) have been used as part of modular hip replacements since the early 2000’s but these were recalled in 2011 by the US Food & Drug Administration (FDA) due to unacceptable levels of ‘wear debris’. The wear was caused by small relative movement of the stem and neck at the junction where they fit together in the modular hip replacement design. In this study, the corrosion and wear properties of the TMZF alloy were investigated in simulated body fluid to identify the reason for the wear debris generation. Ti64 was used as a control for comparison. It is shown that the interaction between the surfaces of Ti64 and TMZF with simulated body fluid is very similar, both from the point of view of the products formed and the kinetics of the reaction. The dry wear behaviour of TMZF is also close to that of Ti64 and consistent with expectations based on Archard's law for abrasive wear. However, wear of Ti64 and TMZF in simulated body fluid show contrasting behaviours. A type of time-dependent wear test is used to examine the synergy between corrosion and wear of TMZF and Ti64. It is shown that the wear of TMZF accelerated rapidly in SBF whereas that of Ti64 is reduced. The critical role of the strain hardening capacity of the two materials and its role in helping the surface resist abrasion by hydroxyapatite particles formed as a result of the reaction with the SBF is discussed and recommendations are made for modifications that could be made to the TMZF alloy to improve the corrosion-wear response. Statement of Significance TMZF is a low modulus β-Ti alloy that has been used as the femoral stem in the Stryker modular design total hip replacement. It went into service in the early 2000’s but was recalled by the FDA in 2011 due to unacceptable levels of wear debris released in the body which led to adverse physiological reactions. A large number of these implants remain in patients today. In this contribution, we investigate the corrosion (interaction of the alloy with simulated body fluid (SBF)), dry wear and then corrosion-wear in SBF to identify the origin of the unacceptable levels of wear that led to the FDA recall of this material. We use Ti-6Al-4V as a control and demonstrate that the reaction between Ti64 and TMZF with SBF is very similar in terms of both products formed and kinetics. We also show that the dry wear behaviour of TMZF is very similar to that of Ti64 and exactly as should be expected for the hardness of this material. However, the wear behaviours of TMZF and Ti64 are completed different in SBF and wear of TMZF is significantly accelerated in SBF. A type of time-dependent wear test is used to demonstrate the synergy between corrosion and wear and the key role of the strain hardening capacity (or lack thereof in the case of β-Ti) is discussed.

KW - TMZF

KW - Ti64

KW - Corrosion-wear

KW - Hip-implant

KW - Simulated body fluid

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84983334412&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.actbio.2016.07.008

DO - 10.1016/j.actbio.2016.07.008

M3 - Article

VL - 42

SP - 429

EP - 439

JO - Acta Biomaterialia

JF - Acta Biomaterialia

SN - 1742-7061

ER -