Contra Kant: Experimental ethics in Guyau and Kant

Keith Ansell-Pearson, Michael Vincent Ure

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (Book)Researchpeer-review

Abstract

Powerful critiques of Kantian ethics are mounted towards the end of the nineteenth century by naturalistic-minded philosophers such as Jean-Marie Guyau (1854-88) and Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900). This chapter examines the basis of these critiques and what, if anything, they have in common. The aim of such critiques is to challenge the universalist assumptions of Kantian ethics and favour instead a genuinely experimental ethics, one that is premised on a commitment to moral variability and that seeks to promote heterodox forms of living. As Nietzsche puts it in his text of 1881, Dawn, the idea of'the human being' is a 'bloodless abstraction' and 'fiction' (D 105, KSA 3.93). But on what precise grounds do figures such as Guyau and Nietzsche challenge universalism in ethics? And what kind of future for ethical life do they envisage? Here we are not so much concerned with whether these figures get Kant right, but with exploring the nature of their experimentalism and its grounds.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationNietzsche’s Engagements with Kant and the Kantian Legacy; Volume II
Subtitle of host publicationNietzsche and Kantian Ethics
EditorsJoao Constancio, Tom Bailey
Place of PublicationLondon UK
PublisherBloomsbury Academic
Pages257-289
Number of pages33
Volume2
Edition1st
ISBN (Electronic)9781350035577, 9781350035584
ISBN (Print)9781474275958
Publication statusPublished - 2017

Publication series

NameNietzsche’s Engagements with Kant and the Kantian Legacy
PublisherBloomsbury Academic

Keywords

  • Ethics
  • Kant
  • Nietzsche
  • Guyau

Cite this

Ansell-Pearson, K., & Ure, M. V. (2017). Contra Kant: Experimental ethics in Guyau and Kant. In J. Constancio, & T. Bailey (Eds.), Nietzsche’s Engagements with Kant and the Kantian Legacy; Volume II : Nietzsche and Kantian Ethics (1st ed., Vol. 2, pp. 257-289). (Nietzsche’s Engagements with Kant and the Kantian Legacy). London UK: Bloomsbury Academic.
Ansell-Pearson, Keith ; Ure, Michael Vincent. / Contra Kant: Experimental ethics in Guyau and Kant. Nietzsche’s Engagements with Kant and the Kantian Legacy; Volume II : Nietzsche and Kantian Ethics. editor / Joao Constancio ; Tom Bailey. Vol. 2 1st. ed. London UK : Bloomsbury Academic, 2017. pp. 257-289 (Nietzsche’s Engagements with Kant and the Kantian Legacy).
@inbook{aba0ac1af85047feb96cdc5659f33ffd,
title = "Contra Kant:: Experimental ethics in Guyau and Kant",
abstract = "Powerful critiques of Kantian ethics are mounted towards the end of the nineteenth century by naturalistic-minded philosophers such as Jean-Marie Guyau (1854-88) and Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900). This chapter examines the basis of these critiques and what, if anything, they have in common. The aim of such critiques is to challenge the universalist assumptions of Kantian ethics and favour instead a genuinely experimental ethics, one that is premised on a commitment to moral variability and that seeks to promote heterodox forms of living. As Nietzsche puts it in his text of 1881, Dawn, the idea of'the human being' is a 'bloodless abstraction' and 'fiction' (D 105, KSA 3.93). But on what precise grounds do figures such as Guyau and Nietzsche challenge universalism in ethics? And what kind of future for ethical life do they envisage? Here we are not so much concerned with whether these figures get Kant right, but with exploring the nature of their experimentalism and its grounds.",
keywords = "Ethics, Kant, Nietzsche, Guyau",
author = "Keith Ansell-Pearson and Ure, {Michael Vincent}",
year = "2017",
language = "English",
isbn = "9781474275958",
volume = "2",
series = "Nietzsche’s Engagements with Kant and the Kantian Legacy",
publisher = "Bloomsbury Academic",
pages = "257--289",
editor = "Joao Constancio and Bailey, {Tom }",
booktitle = "Nietzsche’s Engagements with Kant and the Kantian Legacy; Volume II",
edition = "1st",

}

Ansell-Pearson, K & Ure, MV 2017, Contra Kant: Experimental ethics in Guyau and Kant. in J Constancio & T Bailey (eds), Nietzsche’s Engagements with Kant and the Kantian Legacy; Volume II : Nietzsche and Kantian Ethics. 1st edn, vol. 2, Nietzsche’s Engagements with Kant and the Kantian Legacy, Bloomsbury Academic, London UK, pp. 257-289.

Contra Kant: Experimental ethics in Guyau and Kant. / Ansell-Pearson, Keith; Ure, Michael Vincent.

Nietzsche’s Engagements with Kant and the Kantian Legacy; Volume II : Nietzsche and Kantian Ethics. ed. / Joao Constancio; Tom Bailey. Vol. 2 1st. ed. London UK : Bloomsbury Academic, 2017. p. 257-289 (Nietzsche’s Engagements with Kant and the Kantian Legacy).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (Book)Researchpeer-review

TY - CHAP

T1 - Contra Kant:

T2 - Experimental ethics in Guyau and Kant

AU - Ansell-Pearson, Keith

AU - Ure, Michael Vincent

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - Powerful critiques of Kantian ethics are mounted towards the end of the nineteenth century by naturalistic-minded philosophers such as Jean-Marie Guyau (1854-88) and Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900). This chapter examines the basis of these critiques and what, if anything, they have in common. The aim of such critiques is to challenge the universalist assumptions of Kantian ethics and favour instead a genuinely experimental ethics, one that is premised on a commitment to moral variability and that seeks to promote heterodox forms of living. As Nietzsche puts it in his text of 1881, Dawn, the idea of'the human being' is a 'bloodless abstraction' and 'fiction' (D 105, KSA 3.93). But on what precise grounds do figures such as Guyau and Nietzsche challenge universalism in ethics? And what kind of future for ethical life do they envisage? Here we are not so much concerned with whether these figures get Kant right, but with exploring the nature of their experimentalism and its grounds.

AB - Powerful critiques of Kantian ethics are mounted towards the end of the nineteenth century by naturalistic-minded philosophers such as Jean-Marie Guyau (1854-88) and Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900). This chapter examines the basis of these critiques and what, if anything, they have in common. The aim of such critiques is to challenge the universalist assumptions of Kantian ethics and favour instead a genuinely experimental ethics, one that is premised on a commitment to moral variability and that seeks to promote heterodox forms of living. As Nietzsche puts it in his text of 1881, Dawn, the idea of'the human being' is a 'bloodless abstraction' and 'fiction' (D 105, KSA 3.93). But on what precise grounds do figures such as Guyau and Nietzsche challenge universalism in ethics? And what kind of future for ethical life do they envisage? Here we are not so much concerned with whether these figures get Kant right, but with exploring the nature of their experimentalism and its grounds.

KW - Ethics

KW - Kant

KW - Nietzsche

KW - Guyau

M3 - Chapter (Book)

SN - 9781474275958

VL - 2

T3 - Nietzsche’s Engagements with Kant and the Kantian Legacy

SP - 257

EP - 289

BT - Nietzsche’s Engagements with Kant and the Kantian Legacy; Volume II

A2 - Constancio, Joao

A2 - Bailey, Tom

PB - Bloomsbury Academic

CY - London UK

ER -

Ansell-Pearson K, Ure MV. Contra Kant: Experimental ethics in Guyau and Kant. In Constancio J, Bailey T, editors, Nietzsche’s Engagements with Kant and the Kantian Legacy; Volume II : Nietzsche and Kantian Ethics. 1st ed. Vol. 2. London UK: Bloomsbury Academic. 2017. p. 257-289. (Nietzsche’s Engagements with Kant and the Kantian Legacy).