Avoiding Node Re-Expansions Can Break Symmetry Breaking

Symmetry breaking and weighted-suboptimal search are two popular speed-up techniques used in pathfinding search. It is a commonly held assumption that they are orthogonal and easily combined. In this paper we illustrate that this is not necessarily the case when combining a number of symmetry breaking methods, based on Jump Point Search, with Weighted A*, a bounded suboptimal search approach which does not require node re-expansions. Surprisingly, the combination of these two methods can cause search to fail, finding no path to a target node when clearly such paths exist. We demonstrate this phenomenon and show how we can modify the combination to always succeed with low overhead.