A Review of convenience voting in the state of Victoria

Narelle Miragliotta, Matthew Earnest Colin Laing, Paul Thornton-Smith

Research output: Book/ReportCommissioned ReportOther

Abstract

This study used a mixed method research design to explore how voters, legislators and electoral commissions perceive the challenges presented by the extension of convenience voting – both in terms of its growing use among electors and the liberalisation of its forms.

The findings suggest that these groups perceive the challenges associated with the expansion of convenience voting differently.

Voters showed awareness of the possible security risks associated with newer forms of convenience voting but trust that electoral authorities will manage and mitigate these hazards. Voters gave priority to a flexible voting experience.

Legislators expressed concern that convenience voting limited their opportunities to engage with voters during the election campaign period, especially early in-person voters. Many also gave voice to fears that convenience voting will erode democratic engagement. Legislators had a more cautious outlook towards convenience voting, placing a higher value on the security of ballot over voter convenience.

Electoral authorities stressed the multifaceted logistical challenges that the expansion of convenience voting presents for the integrity and efficiency of the electoral process. Their concerns centred on the management of these complex processes. Authorities emphasized the importance of enhancing the voter experience and the electoral process more generally. They sought to balance the goal of convenience against the values of security and efficiency.
Unsurprisingly, the stakeholders’ construction of the challenges that convenience voting can give rise to was consistent with their particular relationship to the electoral process. Yet leaving aside these differences, all agree that a paradigmatic shift in voting is ultimately underway.
Original languageEnglish
PublisherElectoral Regulation Research Network
Commissioning bodyElectoral Regulation Research Network
Number of pages58
Publication statusPublished - 11 Oct 2018

Cite this

Miragliotta, N., Laing, M. E. C., & Thornton-Smith, P. (2018). A Review of convenience voting in the state of Victoria. Electoral Regulation Research Network.
Miragliotta, Narelle ; Laing, Matthew Earnest Colin ; Thornton-Smith, Paul. / A Review of convenience voting in the state of Victoria. Electoral Regulation Research Network, 2018. 58 p.
@book{cf4b94380ab64bdda67ff5ea132c5768,
title = "A Review of convenience voting in the state of Victoria",
abstract = "This study used a mixed method research design to explore how voters, legislators and electoral commissions perceive the challenges presented by the extension of convenience voting – both in terms of its growing use among electors and the liberalisation of its forms.The findings suggest that these groups perceive the challenges associated with the expansion of convenience voting differently.Voters showed awareness of the possible security risks associated with newer forms of convenience voting but trust that electoral authorities will manage and mitigate these hazards. Voters gave priority to a flexible voting experience.Legislators expressed concern that convenience voting limited their opportunities to engage with voters during the election campaign period, especially early in-person voters. Many also gave voice to fears that convenience voting will erode democratic engagement. Legislators had a more cautious outlook towards convenience voting, placing a higher value on the security of ballot over voter convenience.Electoral authorities stressed the multifaceted logistical challenges that the expansion of convenience voting presents for the integrity and efficiency of the electoral process. Their concerns centred on the management of these complex processes. Authorities emphasized the importance of enhancing the voter experience and the electoral process more generally. They sought to balance the goal of convenience against the values of security and efficiency.Unsurprisingly, the stakeholders’ construction of the challenges that convenience voting can give rise to was consistent with their particular relationship to the electoral process. Yet leaving aside these differences, all agree that a paradigmatic shift in voting is ultimately underway.",
author = "Narelle Miragliotta and Laing, {Matthew Earnest Colin} and Paul Thornton-Smith",
year = "2018",
month = "10",
day = "11",
language = "English",
publisher = "Electoral Regulation Research Network",

}

Miragliotta, N, Laing, MEC & Thornton-Smith, P 2018, A Review of convenience voting in the state of Victoria. Electoral Regulation Research Network.

A Review of convenience voting in the state of Victoria. / Miragliotta, Narelle; Laing, Matthew Earnest Colin; Thornton-Smith, Paul.

Electoral Regulation Research Network, 2018. 58 p.

Research output: Book/ReportCommissioned ReportOther

TY - BOOK

T1 - A Review of convenience voting in the state of Victoria

AU - Miragliotta, Narelle

AU - Laing, Matthew Earnest Colin

AU - Thornton-Smith, Paul

PY - 2018/10/11

Y1 - 2018/10/11

N2 - This study used a mixed method research design to explore how voters, legislators and electoral commissions perceive the challenges presented by the extension of convenience voting – both in terms of its growing use among electors and the liberalisation of its forms.The findings suggest that these groups perceive the challenges associated with the expansion of convenience voting differently.Voters showed awareness of the possible security risks associated with newer forms of convenience voting but trust that electoral authorities will manage and mitigate these hazards. Voters gave priority to a flexible voting experience.Legislators expressed concern that convenience voting limited their opportunities to engage with voters during the election campaign period, especially early in-person voters. Many also gave voice to fears that convenience voting will erode democratic engagement. Legislators had a more cautious outlook towards convenience voting, placing a higher value on the security of ballot over voter convenience.Electoral authorities stressed the multifaceted logistical challenges that the expansion of convenience voting presents for the integrity and efficiency of the electoral process. Their concerns centred on the management of these complex processes. Authorities emphasized the importance of enhancing the voter experience and the electoral process more generally. They sought to balance the goal of convenience against the values of security and efficiency.Unsurprisingly, the stakeholders’ construction of the challenges that convenience voting can give rise to was consistent with their particular relationship to the electoral process. Yet leaving aside these differences, all agree that a paradigmatic shift in voting is ultimately underway.

AB - This study used a mixed method research design to explore how voters, legislators and electoral commissions perceive the challenges presented by the extension of convenience voting – both in terms of its growing use among electors and the liberalisation of its forms.The findings suggest that these groups perceive the challenges associated with the expansion of convenience voting differently.Voters showed awareness of the possible security risks associated with newer forms of convenience voting but trust that electoral authorities will manage and mitigate these hazards. Voters gave priority to a flexible voting experience.Legislators expressed concern that convenience voting limited their opportunities to engage with voters during the election campaign period, especially early in-person voters. Many also gave voice to fears that convenience voting will erode democratic engagement. Legislators had a more cautious outlook towards convenience voting, placing a higher value on the security of ballot over voter convenience.Electoral authorities stressed the multifaceted logistical challenges that the expansion of convenience voting presents for the integrity and efficiency of the electoral process. Their concerns centred on the management of these complex processes. Authorities emphasized the importance of enhancing the voter experience and the electoral process more generally. They sought to balance the goal of convenience against the values of security and efficiency.Unsurprisingly, the stakeholders’ construction of the challenges that convenience voting can give rise to was consistent with their particular relationship to the electoral process. Yet leaving aside these differences, all agree that a paradigmatic shift in voting is ultimately underway.

UR - https://law.unimelb.edu.au/centres/errn/research/research-projects/the-desirability-and-feasibility-of-convenience-voting-in-australia-project

M3 - Commissioned Report

BT - A Review of convenience voting in the state of Victoria

PB - Electoral Regulation Research Network

ER -

Miragliotta N, Laing MEC, Thornton-Smith P. A Review of convenience voting in the state of Victoria. Electoral Regulation Research Network, 2018. 58 p.