A paradoxical dynamic in a service labyrinth: insights from HIV care

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Purpose: While theories of complex service systems have advanced important insights about integrated care, less attention has been paid to social dynamics in systems with finite resources. This paper aims to uncover a paradoxical social dynamic undermining the objective of integrated care within an HIV care service system. 

Design/methodology/approach: Grounded in a hermeneutic analysis of depth interviews with 26 people living with HIV/AIDS (PLWHA) and drawing on Bourdieu’s (1984) theory of capital consumption to unpack dynamics of power, struggle and contestation, the authors introduce the concept of the service labyrinth. 

Findings: To competently navigate the service labyrinth of HIV care, consumers adopt capital consumption practices. Paradoxically, these practices enhance empowerment at the individual level but contribute to the fragmentation of the HIV care labyrinth at the system level, ultimately undermining integrated care. 

Research limitations/implications: This study enhances understanding of integrated care in three ways. First, the metaphor of the service labyrinth can be used to better understand complex care-related service systems. Second, as consumers of care enact capital consumption practices, the authors demonstrate how they do not merely experience but actively shape the care system. Third, fragmentation is expectedly part of the human dynamics in complex service systems. Thus, the authors discuss its implications. Further research should investigate whether a similar paradox undermines integrated care in better resourced systems, acute care systems and systems embedded in other cultural contexts. 

Originality/value: Contrasted to provider-centric views of service systems, this study explicates a customer-centric view from the perspective of heterosexual PLWHA.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)2252-2265
Number of pages14
JournalEuropean Journal of Marketing
Volume52
Issue number11
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2018

Keywords

  • Capital consumption
  • Complex service systems
  • HIV care
  • Integrated care
  • Service fragmentation
  • Service labyrinth

Cite this

@article{9c9979433ae44301a19fba0866a1669a,
title = "A paradoxical dynamic in a service labyrinth: insights from HIV care",
abstract = "Purpose: While theories of complex service systems have advanced important insights about integrated care, less attention has been paid to social dynamics in systems with finite resources. This paper aims to uncover a paradoxical social dynamic undermining the objective of integrated care within an HIV care service system. Design/methodology/approach: Grounded in a hermeneutic analysis of depth interviews with 26 people living with HIV/AIDS (PLWHA) and drawing on Bourdieu’s (1984) theory of capital consumption to unpack dynamics of power, struggle and contestation, the authors introduce the concept of the service labyrinth. Findings: To competently navigate the service labyrinth of HIV care, consumers adopt capital consumption practices. Paradoxically, these practices enhance empowerment at the individual level but contribute to the fragmentation of the HIV care labyrinth at the system level, ultimately undermining integrated care. Research limitations/implications: This study enhances understanding of integrated care in three ways. First, the metaphor of the service labyrinth can be used to better understand complex care-related service systems. Second, as consumers of care enact capital consumption practices, the authors demonstrate how they do not merely experience but actively shape the care system. Third, fragmentation is expectedly part of the human dynamics in complex service systems. Thus, the authors discuss its implications. Further research should investigate whether a similar paradox undermines integrated care in better resourced systems, acute care systems and systems embedded in other cultural contexts. Originality/value: Contrasted to provider-centric views of service systems, this study explicates a customer-centric view from the perspective of heterosexual PLWHA.",
keywords = "Capital consumption, Complex service systems, HIV care, Integrated care, Service fragmentation, Service labyrinth",
author = "Cruz, {Angela Gracia B.} and Elizabeth Snuggs and Yelena Tsarenko",
year = "2018",
doi = "10.1108/EJM-12-2016-0822",
language = "English",
volume = "52",
pages = "2252--2265",
journal = "European Journal of Marketing",
issn = "0309-0566",
publisher = "Emerald",
number = "11",

}

A paradoxical dynamic in a service labyrinth : insights from HIV care. / Cruz, Angela Gracia B.; Snuggs, Elizabeth; Tsarenko, Yelena.

In: European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 52, No. 11, 2018, p. 2252-2265.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - A paradoxical dynamic in a service labyrinth

T2 - insights from HIV care

AU - Cruz, Angela Gracia B.

AU - Snuggs, Elizabeth

AU - Tsarenko, Yelena

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - Purpose: While theories of complex service systems have advanced important insights about integrated care, less attention has been paid to social dynamics in systems with finite resources. This paper aims to uncover a paradoxical social dynamic undermining the objective of integrated care within an HIV care service system. Design/methodology/approach: Grounded in a hermeneutic analysis of depth interviews with 26 people living with HIV/AIDS (PLWHA) and drawing on Bourdieu’s (1984) theory of capital consumption to unpack dynamics of power, struggle and contestation, the authors introduce the concept of the service labyrinth. Findings: To competently navigate the service labyrinth of HIV care, consumers adopt capital consumption practices. Paradoxically, these practices enhance empowerment at the individual level but contribute to the fragmentation of the HIV care labyrinth at the system level, ultimately undermining integrated care. Research limitations/implications: This study enhances understanding of integrated care in three ways. First, the metaphor of the service labyrinth can be used to better understand complex care-related service systems. Second, as consumers of care enact capital consumption practices, the authors demonstrate how they do not merely experience but actively shape the care system. Third, fragmentation is expectedly part of the human dynamics in complex service systems. Thus, the authors discuss its implications. Further research should investigate whether a similar paradox undermines integrated care in better resourced systems, acute care systems and systems embedded in other cultural contexts. Originality/value: Contrasted to provider-centric views of service systems, this study explicates a customer-centric view from the perspective of heterosexual PLWHA.

AB - Purpose: While theories of complex service systems have advanced important insights about integrated care, less attention has been paid to social dynamics in systems with finite resources. This paper aims to uncover a paradoxical social dynamic undermining the objective of integrated care within an HIV care service system. Design/methodology/approach: Grounded in a hermeneutic analysis of depth interviews with 26 people living with HIV/AIDS (PLWHA) and drawing on Bourdieu’s (1984) theory of capital consumption to unpack dynamics of power, struggle and contestation, the authors introduce the concept of the service labyrinth. Findings: To competently navigate the service labyrinth of HIV care, consumers adopt capital consumption practices. Paradoxically, these practices enhance empowerment at the individual level but contribute to the fragmentation of the HIV care labyrinth at the system level, ultimately undermining integrated care. Research limitations/implications: This study enhances understanding of integrated care in three ways. First, the metaphor of the service labyrinth can be used to better understand complex care-related service systems. Second, as consumers of care enact capital consumption practices, the authors demonstrate how they do not merely experience but actively shape the care system. Third, fragmentation is expectedly part of the human dynamics in complex service systems. Thus, the authors discuss its implications. Further research should investigate whether a similar paradox undermines integrated care in better resourced systems, acute care systems and systems embedded in other cultural contexts. Originality/value: Contrasted to provider-centric views of service systems, this study explicates a customer-centric view from the perspective of heterosexual PLWHA.

KW - Capital consumption

KW - Complex service systems

KW - HIV care

KW - Integrated care

KW - Service fragmentation

KW - Service labyrinth

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85054541461&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1108/EJM-12-2016-0822

DO - 10.1108/EJM-12-2016-0822

M3 - Article

VL - 52

SP - 2252

EP - 2265

JO - European Journal of Marketing

JF - European Journal of Marketing

SN - 0309-0566

IS - 11

ER -