A comparative institutional analysis on strategies that graduates use to show they are ‘employable’

a critical discussion on the cases of Australia, Japan, and Vietnam

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Employability has become a key concept that has attracted the attention of scholars and industries in many countries. At the same time, this concept is highly fluid and vague because its nature is not evidenced by real employment and differences in the nature of labour markets from country to country. Thus, it would be more worthwhile to discuss strategies that graduates utilise while job hunting in order to show how employable they are, and then compare these strategies across countries. Therefore, in this study, the aim is to compare the strategic tendencies of graduates entering the labour markets in three countries: Australia, Japan, and Vietnam. To this end, a comparative institutional analysis is performed. Through the investigation, three types of strategy are identified. In Australia, as the market tends to consist of various competitors with different experiences, graduates must differentiate themselves from others. In Japan, the market consists of competitors from the same academic year cohort and employment tends to be more long term, so employment is seen more as a type of membership, where one must match the corporate culture. In Vietnam, as trust in universities is low in terms of their training programmes and little support is provided, university students utilise their human networks for entry into the labour market and demonstrate their capacity for growth during a probation period.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)369-382
Number of pages14
JournalHigher Education Research and Development
Volume38
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2019

Keywords

  • comparative institutional analysis
  • Employability
  • job hunting
  • labour market

Cite this

@article{dd9388228b55466c9636bcc75ef0c3e7,
title = "A comparative institutional analysis on strategies that graduates use to show they are ‘employable’: a critical discussion on the cases of Australia, Japan, and Vietnam",
abstract = "Employability has become a key concept that has attracted the attention of scholars and industries in many countries. At the same time, this concept is highly fluid and vague because its nature is not evidenced by real employment and differences in the nature of labour markets from country to country. Thus, it would be more worthwhile to discuss strategies that graduates utilise while job hunting in order to show how employable they are, and then compare these strategies across countries. Therefore, in this study, the aim is to compare the strategic tendencies of graduates entering the labour markets in three countries: Australia, Japan, and Vietnam. To this end, a comparative institutional analysis is performed. Through the investigation, three types of strategy are identified. In Australia, as the market tends to consist of various competitors with different experiences, graduates must differentiate themselves from others. In Japan, the market consists of competitors from the same academic year cohort and employment tends to be more long term, so employment is seen more as a type of membership, where one must match the corporate culture. In Vietnam, as trust in universities is low in terms of their training programmes and little support is provided, university students utilise their human networks for entry into the labour market and demonstrate their capacity for growth during a probation period.",
keywords = "comparative institutional analysis, Employability, job hunting, labour market",
author = "Eisuke Saito and Pham, {Thanh Hong Thi}",
year = "2019",
doi = "10.1080/07294360.2018.1529024",
language = "English",
volume = "38",
pages = "369--382",
journal = "Higher Education Research and Development",
issn = "0729-4360",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A comparative institutional analysis on strategies that graduates use to show they are ‘employable’

T2 - a critical discussion on the cases of Australia, Japan, and Vietnam

AU - Saito, Eisuke

AU - Pham, Thanh Hong Thi

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - Employability has become a key concept that has attracted the attention of scholars and industries in many countries. At the same time, this concept is highly fluid and vague because its nature is not evidenced by real employment and differences in the nature of labour markets from country to country. Thus, it would be more worthwhile to discuss strategies that graduates utilise while job hunting in order to show how employable they are, and then compare these strategies across countries. Therefore, in this study, the aim is to compare the strategic tendencies of graduates entering the labour markets in three countries: Australia, Japan, and Vietnam. To this end, a comparative institutional analysis is performed. Through the investigation, three types of strategy are identified. In Australia, as the market tends to consist of various competitors with different experiences, graduates must differentiate themselves from others. In Japan, the market consists of competitors from the same academic year cohort and employment tends to be more long term, so employment is seen more as a type of membership, where one must match the corporate culture. In Vietnam, as trust in universities is low in terms of their training programmes and little support is provided, university students utilise their human networks for entry into the labour market and demonstrate their capacity for growth during a probation period.

AB - Employability has become a key concept that has attracted the attention of scholars and industries in many countries. At the same time, this concept is highly fluid and vague because its nature is not evidenced by real employment and differences in the nature of labour markets from country to country. Thus, it would be more worthwhile to discuss strategies that graduates utilise while job hunting in order to show how employable they are, and then compare these strategies across countries. Therefore, in this study, the aim is to compare the strategic tendencies of graduates entering the labour markets in three countries: Australia, Japan, and Vietnam. To this end, a comparative institutional analysis is performed. Through the investigation, three types of strategy are identified. In Australia, as the market tends to consist of various competitors with different experiences, graduates must differentiate themselves from others. In Japan, the market consists of competitors from the same academic year cohort and employment tends to be more long term, so employment is seen more as a type of membership, where one must match the corporate culture. In Vietnam, as trust in universities is low in terms of their training programmes and little support is provided, university students utilise their human networks for entry into the labour market and demonstrate their capacity for growth during a probation period.

KW - comparative institutional analysis

KW - Employability

KW - job hunting

KW - labour market

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85054587377&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/07294360.2018.1529024

DO - 10.1080/07294360.2018.1529024

M3 - Article

VL - 38

SP - 369

EP - 382

JO - Higher Education Research and Development

JF - Higher Education Research and Development

SN - 0729-4360

IS - 2

ER -