A cellular automata fast flood evaluation (CA-ffé) model

Behzad Jamali, Peter M. Bach, Luke Cunningham, Ana Deletic

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The simulation speed of two-dimensional hydrodynamic flood models is a limiting factor when catchments are large, a considerable number of simulations is required (e.g., exploratory modeling, Monte-Carlo flood simulations, or predicting probabilistic flood maps), or when there is a need for real-time flood emergency management. Rapid Flood Models (RFMs) that rely only on topographic depressions and the water balance equation have been successfully implemented to predict maximum urban flood inundation depths within seconds to a few minutes. However, the preprocessing step (identification of depressions and their attributes) and the postprocessing step (marking up possible flow paths of flood water in between flooded depressions) of RFMs is time consuming. In this study, we developed a new fast flood inundation model based on the cellular automata (CA) approach. The new model does not require the preprocessing and postprocessing steps of RFMs and therefore can provide more simulation speed. The performance of our new model, referred to as Cellular Automata fast flood evaluation (CA-ffé), was compared to two well-known hydrodynamic flood models (HEC-RAS and TUFLOW) in 20 simulation experiments conducted in five different urban subcatchments. CA-ffé predicted maximum inundation depth with reasonable accuracy in a matter of seconds to a few minutes for a single rainfall event simulation. The CA-ffé model performed exceptionally well in areas with low-lying depressions. However, in areas where floodwaters had higher momentum and velocity, the model usually was not able to estimate inundation depths calculated by HEC-RAS or TUFLOW. CA-ffé's key drawback is also its inability to represent the temporal evolution of flooding and flow velocities. Nevertheless, its ability to provide spatial flood extents and depths in a fraction of the time compared to its hydrodynamic counterparts is a significant advancement toward exploratory approaches for water systems planning, model-based predictive control, and real-time flood management.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)4936-4953
Number of pages18
JournalWater Resources Research
Volume55
Issue number6
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jun 2019

Keywords

  • Cellular Automata (CA)
  • HEC-RAS
  • rapid flood inundation models
  • TUFLOW
  • urban pluvial flooding

Cite this

Jamali, Behzad ; Bach, Peter M. ; Cunningham, Luke ; Deletic, Ana. / A cellular automata fast flood evaluation (CA-ffé) model. In: Water Resources Research. 2019 ; Vol. 55, No. 6. pp. 4936-4953.
@article{744206b5cebb481fbcf502fa27def0d4,
title = "A cellular automata fast flood evaluation (CA-ff{\'e}) model",
abstract = "The simulation speed of two-dimensional hydrodynamic flood models is a limiting factor when catchments are large, a considerable number of simulations is required (e.g., exploratory modeling, Monte-Carlo flood simulations, or predicting probabilistic flood maps), or when there is a need for real-time flood emergency management. Rapid Flood Models (RFMs) that rely only on topographic depressions and the water balance equation have been successfully implemented to predict maximum urban flood inundation depths within seconds to a few minutes. However, the preprocessing step (identification of depressions and their attributes) and the postprocessing step (marking up possible flow paths of flood water in between flooded depressions) of RFMs is time consuming. In this study, we developed a new fast flood inundation model based on the cellular automata (CA) approach. The new model does not require the preprocessing and postprocessing steps of RFMs and therefore can provide more simulation speed. The performance of our new model, referred to as Cellular Automata fast flood evaluation (CA-ff{\'e}), was compared to two well-known hydrodynamic flood models (HEC-RAS and TUFLOW) in 20 simulation experiments conducted in five different urban subcatchments. CA-ff{\'e} predicted maximum inundation depth with reasonable accuracy in a matter of seconds to a few minutes for a single rainfall event simulation. The CA-ff{\'e} model performed exceptionally well in areas with low-lying depressions. However, in areas where floodwaters had higher momentum and velocity, the model usually was not able to estimate inundation depths calculated by HEC-RAS or TUFLOW. CA-ff{\'e}'s key drawback is also its inability to represent the temporal evolution of flooding and flow velocities. Nevertheless, its ability to provide spatial flood extents and depths in a fraction of the time compared to its hydrodynamic counterparts is a significant advancement toward exploratory approaches for water systems planning, model-based predictive control, and real-time flood management.",
keywords = "Cellular Automata (CA), HEC-RAS, rapid flood inundation models, TUFLOW, urban pluvial flooding",
author = "Behzad Jamali and Bach, {Peter M.} and Luke Cunningham and Ana Deletic",
year = "2019",
month = "6",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1029/2018WR023679",
language = "English",
volume = "55",
pages = "4936--4953",
journal = "Water Resources Research",
issn = "0043-1397",
publisher = "American Geophysical Union",
number = "6",

}

A cellular automata fast flood evaluation (CA-ffé) model. / Jamali, Behzad; Bach, Peter M.; Cunningham, Luke; Deletic, Ana.

In: Water Resources Research, Vol. 55, No. 6, 01.06.2019, p. 4936-4953.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - A cellular automata fast flood evaluation (CA-ffé) model

AU - Jamali, Behzad

AU - Bach, Peter M.

AU - Cunningham, Luke

AU - Deletic, Ana

PY - 2019/6/1

Y1 - 2019/6/1

N2 - The simulation speed of two-dimensional hydrodynamic flood models is a limiting factor when catchments are large, a considerable number of simulations is required (e.g., exploratory modeling, Monte-Carlo flood simulations, or predicting probabilistic flood maps), or when there is a need for real-time flood emergency management. Rapid Flood Models (RFMs) that rely only on topographic depressions and the water balance equation have been successfully implemented to predict maximum urban flood inundation depths within seconds to a few minutes. However, the preprocessing step (identification of depressions and their attributes) and the postprocessing step (marking up possible flow paths of flood water in between flooded depressions) of RFMs is time consuming. In this study, we developed a new fast flood inundation model based on the cellular automata (CA) approach. The new model does not require the preprocessing and postprocessing steps of RFMs and therefore can provide more simulation speed. The performance of our new model, referred to as Cellular Automata fast flood evaluation (CA-ffé), was compared to two well-known hydrodynamic flood models (HEC-RAS and TUFLOW) in 20 simulation experiments conducted in five different urban subcatchments. CA-ffé predicted maximum inundation depth with reasonable accuracy in a matter of seconds to a few minutes for a single rainfall event simulation. The CA-ffé model performed exceptionally well in areas with low-lying depressions. However, in areas where floodwaters had higher momentum and velocity, the model usually was not able to estimate inundation depths calculated by HEC-RAS or TUFLOW. CA-ffé's key drawback is also its inability to represent the temporal evolution of flooding and flow velocities. Nevertheless, its ability to provide spatial flood extents and depths in a fraction of the time compared to its hydrodynamic counterparts is a significant advancement toward exploratory approaches for water systems planning, model-based predictive control, and real-time flood management.

AB - The simulation speed of two-dimensional hydrodynamic flood models is a limiting factor when catchments are large, a considerable number of simulations is required (e.g., exploratory modeling, Monte-Carlo flood simulations, or predicting probabilistic flood maps), or when there is a need for real-time flood emergency management. Rapid Flood Models (RFMs) that rely only on topographic depressions and the water balance equation have been successfully implemented to predict maximum urban flood inundation depths within seconds to a few minutes. However, the preprocessing step (identification of depressions and their attributes) and the postprocessing step (marking up possible flow paths of flood water in between flooded depressions) of RFMs is time consuming. In this study, we developed a new fast flood inundation model based on the cellular automata (CA) approach. The new model does not require the preprocessing and postprocessing steps of RFMs and therefore can provide more simulation speed. The performance of our new model, referred to as Cellular Automata fast flood evaluation (CA-ffé), was compared to two well-known hydrodynamic flood models (HEC-RAS and TUFLOW) in 20 simulation experiments conducted in five different urban subcatchments. CA-ffé predicted maximum inundation depth with reasonable accuracy in a matter of seconds to a few minutes for a single rainfall event simulation. The CA-ffé model performed exceptionally well in areas with low-lying depressions. However, in areas where floodwaters had higher momentum and velocity, the model usually was not able to estimate inundation depths calculated by HEC-RAS or TUFLOW. CA-ffé's key drawback is also its inability to represent the temporal evolution of flooding and flow velocities. Nevertheless, its ability to provide spatial flood extents and depths in a fraction of the time compared to its hydrodynamic counterparts is a significant advancement toward exploratory approaches for water systems planning, model-based predictive control, and real-time flood management.

KW - Cellular Automata (CA)

KW - HEC-RAS

KW - rapid flood inundation models

KW - TUFLOW

KW - urban pluvial flooding

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85067879945&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1029/2018WR023679

DO - 10.1029/2018WR023679

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85067879945

VL - 55

SP - 4936

EP - 4953

JO - Water Resources Research

JF - Water Resources Research

SN - 0043-1397

IS - 6

ER -